Order: Iron Rock
Guild Poll closed 9/12/08. Votes below. Discussion continues.
1. Join another guild (or guilds) or create our own.
For Joining: 12
Create our own: 11
Conclusion: Voting on this issue seems even. We have an offer to join up with Control Point in a Destruction guild.
2. Type of Server preference: Core rules, Open, or Roleplaying (all the RP servers right now are Core rules).
I'll give quick definitions:
Core = RvR only in RvR areas (this is a big area in most realms) and scenarios.
Open = RvR everywhere, if you can get to the opposing faction's PvE area you can kill them there.
RP = Core rules, roleplaying limitations on names, roleplaying suggested.
Here is a quick link to a Marc Jacobs post on the subject of servers.
Most votes at present are for Core / Open and against RP. At present Core has 13 more declared votes than Open.
Conclusion: There is a clear GWJ preference for Core rules.
3. Order or Destruction, post a preference if you have one.
Conclusion: There is a GWJ preference for Destruction. However, there will most likely be a GWJ presence on two servers, one in a Destro guild, the other in an Order guild.
4. Server choice?
Discussion closed for now. See top of post.
5. Guild names.
CP may name their guild Target Is Not Attackable, or WARP.
Feel free to discuss names in the thread, but I probably won't have time to tabulate results this weekend.