Cybernookie and the Boys Who Sell it

The armies stand poised, ready for battle. Their mounts steaming with the hard ride to the battlefields, the men and women readying their weapons and soothing excited pets. Just as battle is about to be joined, there rings out the clarion call of a trumpet, like the Grinch returning to Whooville, and in ride a battalion of Amazons, trailed by their tabbies, proudly proclaiming themselves to be the Weird Cat Ladies of Doom, come forth to strike a blow for all that is good and bright in the world. 

It would be hysterical, and that is the vision that popped into my head, when I first saw the call on World of WarcraftÂ's general chat channel that someone was forming a guild, and that the only stated requirements were that all the players had to have human female avatars, and they had to be willing to buy a cat. IÂ'd like to say that the obvious jokes also popped into my head, but let us not get into them, as most involve the Â"pÂ" wordÂ"…a word I find most distasteful. And reallyÂ"…the jokes are so easy my toddler could make them. I consider it noblesse oblige to leave the lower hanging fruit for others.

So, when I asked if they were forming a Weird Cat Lady guild, I was actually being seriousÂ"…because, reallyÂ"…thatÂ's just funny. Imagine my surprise when I was screamed at by the general chat spammer for being a Â"sexist f***ing a**h**** who didnÂ't understand women or catsÂ". When I explained that I was, in fact, actually a woman; with the PMS and the boobs, and the ability to make a grown man beg for mercy, and a proud member of the Weird Cat Lady Society who was the keeper of 3 cats probably older than they were, they mostly went away. (Ok, there was a brief flame war, after which they left the zone because I was humiliating them when it became terribly apparent that they were adolescent boys.)

But you see, IÂ'd had a bottle of wine and the husband had gone to bed. I had nothing better to do than poke the bear. Most of the time, I can ignore the call of the loons, but IÂ'm Mediterranean; for a good time, give me a bottle of wine, point me towards idiots and sit down and watch the spectator sport. So, in my tipsy state, I decided I would log in an unguilded character I had never played and thus would be painless to delete, and find out what exactly they were trying to do, were it to not be the Weird Cat Ladies.

Imagine my surprise to find out that what they were planning was a large-scale cyber-brothel, and that the tabbies would be a Â"signalÂ" that the player was, shall we say, open for tells. Leaving aside the absurdity of the premise that one can be a prostitute in a game where sex isnÂ't possible, I suppose some gamers, (none of us, IÂ'm sure), are desperate enough to pay another character x silver a minute to disrobe, dance and talk dirty in a private channel.

As an aside, for those of you have seen a human female avatar on WoW dance, why would anyone pay to watch the macarena? Night Elves I could see, they get a +40 to pole dancing. Gnomes are apparently born to dance like Tijuana teenagers after a bottle of mescal. But to fantasize about the humans dancing the Macarena? ThatÂ's a level of desperation that bespeaks itself of the Star Trek clad, sweat-befouled 40-somethings who still live in MommyÂ's basement. We should however probably be grateful that they are cybering rather than breeding. Every cloud has a silver lining.

When I mentioned that perhaps this business idea had flaws, in that I couldnÂ't see how there would be much of a market for it, I was told by the head Cat that they had done it on numerous other servers and other games such as EQ and EQ2, and that the most successful Â"girlsÂ", which is to say those that read the script provided and followed the guild Â"rate sheetÂ", made upwards of 10 gold an hour, of which the guild got 20%. The guild cash was then sold on Ebay with the profits going to Head Cat. One assumes that of the thousands of sales for WOW gold on eBay, the guild members are generating some as well.

When I proffered the false information that I was a straight high school guy and that I didnÂ't think I could do it, Head Cat replied that he had just graduated from high school, but that someone Â"who had experience with this sort of thingÂ" had provided the scripts. Suggesting to me that the scheme originates with some deeper connections than just a couple of kids pulling scams.

So, letÂ's think about this. Theoretically, hundreds of gold pieces are being generated by Â"cyber-hookersÂ". Statisticians have estimated that about 11% of female avatars are actually played by women. Ergo, itÂ's a fairly safe assumption that the cyber-hookers are probably being played by boys. Yes, boys. Not men, not women, not girls, but boys. Most adult gamers wouldnÂ't cheapen themselves, or waste valuable game playing time. Most girls gamers would sooner shoot a stranger than cyber with one for money. TheyÂ're gamersÂ"…not bimbos. And in every game where this sort of thing of pops up in any organized format, it always turns out to be led by a cadre of teenage boys. (See Evangeline in Sims Online for another example of organized game prostitution.)

Now, I realize that visiting a comfort girl, either live or virtual, would require some suspension of disbelief. But male gamers have been complaining for years that there werenÂ't enough females that appreciate the skills and time it takes to be a good gamer. The 11% of the population of these worlds who are actual females are a rare breed, so what are the odds that this tiny percentage of gamers would suddenly decide to stop gaming so that they could talk dirty for far less money than they could make if they just did it for one of the thousands of phone services? It boggles the mind to believe that the people who hire these Â"girlsÂ" do it thinking that itÂ's actually a girl.

And it raises interesting questions about ethics, legality and the potential for organized crime. If, in fact, as it appears, these Â"girlsÂ" are actually teenage boys, does that verge into the legal area of child prostitution? Can virtual sex for cash be considered prostitution at all? Is the person providing the scripts breaking any laws by providing pornographic material to minors? Other than the ebaying of the proceeds, are they breaking any of BlizzardÂ's usage rules? Surely visiting a virtual stripper and chat session is a better option than hopping over to Nevada and visiting the real thing, but at what cost to real women who game and would just as soon not be bothered by horny creepoids? Have we crossed a digital divide line into a form of cyborg social experimentation or theory? (See A Manifesto for Cyborgs, Feminist Views of Cybersex, and Cyborgasms and Cyber-sex Amongst Multiple-Selves and Cyborgs in the Narrow-Bandwidth Space.)

As I was pondering these deep thoughts, I got a tell from someone I didnÂ't know, who wanted to know if I Â"wanted to cyb3r!1!Â". My automatic response was Â"Oh, good lord, go away wannabe script kiddie.Â" Thinking back on it, I think my response should have been; Â"The ontology of your cyberdesires leaves me with a stunning case of dualistic ennui, your display of manly l33tness makes me want to sterilize my Ethernet connection, and you should put that thing away before your mom comes in.Â"

Do I Make You Thorny Baby?
Donator V3.0
Alien Love Gardener's picture
Location: Effin' Finland

That's so...I think I'm just going to sit here in stunned silence for a moment.

Excellent article though.

"The secret of life is honesty and fair dealing. If you can fake that, you've got it made."

CEO
Pillow
Elysium's picture

Sometimes it staggers me the breadth of the canyon that separates my perception of the world compared with that of someone who might seek to participate in cybering. It's like trying to look at the world from the perspective of a dirty glass of spoiled milk.

Frankly, I blame pretty much any dime-store fantasy artist who ever drew a voluptuous dark-elf clad only in strategically torn hides mounted (in the classical sense) upon a bristling tiger, for instilling that pitiful fantasy in anyone's mind in the first place.

I felt -- I feel -- that Shawn, Rob and Julian were making out with the game, and as their friend I felt it was important to point out that they were making out with an ugly chick. - Cory Banks, keeping it real

1 Perk Every 1000th Post
Donator V5.0

I believe it is not the manner in which they dance that mesmerizes the boys' eyes, but the fact that females of WoW are animated in a way which makes their breasts bounce ever so slightly when they do.

Consultant
puck4604's picture
Location: Richmond, Kentucky

Ohmygod. It is almost too sad, but quite funny.

Great article, though. I love your writing style, DuckiDeva.

Ph.D. in Awesome
Donator V5.0
Dr._J's picture
Location: Always watching. Always judging.

Hey! I think I just figured out a way to make insanely large piles of gil in Final Fantasy XI. I'll become a digital pimp!. People would just be lining up to see scantly clad Tarutarus bump and grind in provocative ways!

Seriously though, this cyber prostitution thing in WOW will be short lived. Blizzard, being who they are, will quickly descend on these digital brothels with the fury of a pissed off volcano god and soundly smite them. If Blizzard will make you change your character name because it does not fit with the WOW universe, think about how they are going to react to this.

A Mind Without Purpose Will Walk In Dark Places

"I may be out of ammo but I ain't out of chainsaw B*TCHES!" - Sinister's warcry for Gears of War

Conservative Overlord
Donator V9.0
JohnnyMoJo's picture
Location: Atlanta, GA

Great article Ducki. I used to have Wiz-bits on several MUSHes, and the number of people who's idea of 'role-playing' involved typing with one hand was staggering. Given that I could see the email addresses that the players had used to create their accounts, I was amazed by the number of guy-on-guy love sessions that took place. But make no mistake, in those days I'd say that at least 50% of the actual females on the MUSHes would engage in a little hanky-panky.

"It's so much easier to suggest solutions when you don't know too much about the problem." - Malcolm Forbes

Fully Intact
Donator V6.0
JimmDogg's picture
Location: The Sunshine State

Quote:
guy-on-guy love sessions

That's hilarious.

Great article, you even did some "undercover" reporting.

I am seriously enjoying all the new writers. It has really added something to the site, which was already nigh-perfect.

"That's because you were 10. Everyone likes Garfield when they're 10. When you're 10 you think a cat eating lasagna is genius." - Mumford

2005 GWJFFL League Champion

0 to Zen in under 6 seconds
Donator V7.0
karmajay's picture
Location: Belville, NC

Thanks for the read.

Although pretty crazy, you do have to appreciate the person that thought the business model up. Whether it's long lived or not, there will always be people doing these type of business things.

I asked my wife the same thing last night. She replied with "stop being a moron and wash the damned dishes" -- Paleocon asking his wife about zombies

Main Gauche
Donator V9.0
Robear's picture

But remember - video games are not even as complicated as novels; they are not art; they are merely mindless pro-violence timewasters that are beneath even the contempt of society...

Right. Any society, virtual or not, that is robust will have this sort of thing going on in the corners. Another knock in the face for the "it's all just mashing buttons!" brigade.

I'll believe corporations are people when Texas executes one by lethal injection. - Paleocon
We said they were people, we didn't say they were black. - Yonder

Avant-garde Grognard
Donator V4.0
SwampYankee's picture
Location: Drinking Wine, Eating Cheese, Catching Some Rays

Well, that is certainly a new one for me. Yet another look at the human psyche unleashed by the "anonymity" of the net.

I'm starting to wish that Blizzard would have servers for younger kids only, although it would be difficult to enforce. The idea of my 12 year old daughter who plays a Night Elf and has a cat running into these creeps troubles me. And yes, we are usually there with her and we have already had "that talk". She has reported one incident when someone started swearing at her for not helping them fight a monster, and that was addressed.

Just one more turn!
Donator V5.0
Location: Wherever I want to be.

Well, I can say I'm too old for that kind of c***; I'm a gamer first, not a scammer.

But, hey- I have an idea....Certis, Pyro, Flux, et. al. you should start promoting Duckideva's columns as "the female Bill Harris" (of Dubious Quallty fame). That will really bring in the readers/members; err the readers. Their members may stay elsewhere.....

"Eat Keel, Hellbug!"

Useless, Yet Entertaining
Fletcher's picture
Location: Office of the EIC, bitches!

Excellent article Deva.

Of course it means something entirely different when I say "I've a bottle of wine and nothing better to do than poke the bear," but then that's the point isn't it?

You have poetry and style. Long live you.

Don't be saucy with me, Bernaise. - Count DeMonet

FalseGravity - My first blog.

The Escapist - My first Editor-in-Chief job.

Consultant
Location: Chicago

I've talked to many an online friend who found out that their short- or sometimes even long-term digital relationship (which for some reason dove into the realm of cyber) ended up being with someone of their same sex. I've honestly never understood the lure, but perhaps that's because I have good relationship with the wife and I don't need to score online for my good times.

I know I've had guildmates in several games who are females both in game and out and we've never even looked at that road. We've talked about the fun and challenge of raising kids in these trying times, the struggle of going back to college when you're "old", and any assorted other topics. Maybe I am old...

Gotham City is in trouble, so I put on a rubber suit and go save innocents from psychotic men in stage makeup. It's more straightforward than you might think. - Sanjuro

Big Damn Hero
Jeb's picture
Location: Floating down the French Broad.

Well done, Deva. A humorous take on a really nasty situation. I have a wee bitty who's going to want to get lost in these worlds faster than I want to think about- she's my daughter, after all- and it absolutely enrages me to think that she might be exposed to this kind of scum.

Bright side is, I'll have to play right beside her. I can only imagine the conversation with her mom now:

"You're playing AGAIN? Shouldn't you be out cutting the grass/chopping wood/providing food for the table?"

"Sorry honey, I have to protect our progeny from the slime of the multiverse."

Mercury's been in retrograde most of the week. It's like a full moon with a side of kicked-in-the-nuts. -- H.P. Lovesauce

Server Ninja
Pyroman[FO]'s picture
Location: Lexington, KY

That's very messed up in alot of ways but I guess it's inevitable. If there's a way to make money at it in an MMO, there's someone somewhere willing to dupe bored teens into doing it for them and giving back 50%.

I wonder how much organized crime is into this though, that'd be pretty interesting to see.

"Use ActiveX — it’s the PBR of client-side web technology." - hipstergrammers
"Try to offer a free dessert to the universe, to truth. You will fail." - Yelping with Cormac

Insect Politician
The Fly's picture
Location: Both feet lefty. Stepping half correctly.

Nicely written, informative, thought-provoking stuff, Ducki. I'll never look at a female WoW character with a cat the same way again.

XboxLive: Fly GWJ | PSN: The _Fly | Twitter

The Confused Philosopher
Demosthenes's picture
Location: The corner of No and Where...

Well that's.... mildly freaky. Yet somehow, it doesn't entirely surprise me. I heard plenty of tales of cybering in EQ... and while I guess it's better than masturbating alone, it'll never compare to the real thing (at least until those cyber suits I've seen on the Modern Marvels about sex come out... then all bets are off). I figure, if the guys are willing to sink that low, they earn whatever stupid in game stuff they can get... let's just see how they feel about it when they're 30, still virgins, and wanking off to their own scripts ^_^

"Just remember that sometimes you need to allow problems to just roll like water off of a duckilama's back." ~Reaper

Coffee Grinder
Location: Saskatchewan, Canada

Another fantastic rant, DuckiDeva, that I'll be sharing with my non-gaming wife! The last one got her giggling...this one'll have her rolling in the aisles!
Thanks!
Steve

Get Me The Hell Outta Bosnia
el_dino's picture
Location: Vancouver. Yup.

Me loves this site more and more.

Panem et circenses

"You really need to smoke a tree first to appreciate that one." - Sanjuro

The Red
Donator V8.0
Propagandalf's picture

I don't know what is sadder, the fact that this exists or the fact that I'm not suprised it exists and yet I still play WoW. Agreed Swampy, how awesome would it be if we could have adult only servers. Hell, I'd pay an extra fee for that. I shudder when I think about how old some WoW players are.

Drawing on the Cave Wall
Donator V7.0
cartoonin99's picture
Location: Logan, UT

Well, there goes my idea of purchasing a cat in the AH.

Even though my main is a male Night Elf. I get the feeling that some freak of nature will saunter up to me and start sending tells to the tune "Hey dude, you're really a chick, right? You are just playing a guy to throw off the scent, I know how that is. How much for a reach around?"

Aaaaaaaaaaaarrgghhhh!

Quintin_Stone wrote:

Lunabean, when are you going to grow up and stop playing video games?
lunabean wrote:
After I have sex with your mother.

http://steamcommunity.com/id/cartoonin99

Precioussss
Brennil's picture

I wonder if perhaps the people who would pay to see a human female avatar /macarena DO know that it isn't a real live double X behind those jibbling jibblies, and that in fact is why they would choose to slap down their virtual gold. To the average teenager, the opposite sex is so desperately Othered that the prospect of actual interaction on a mere verbal level, nevermind some sort of intimate situation, is terribly frightening.

There are two ways to think about your characters in WoW. One (the one I tend toward) is to see them as an extension of yourself. The other is to see them as a puppet that dances at your command. I doubt if any of the boys running these cyberwhores really sees the dancing girl on their screen as themselves; she is a kind of slave that they are pimping out, rather than being pimped themselves. And the boys who are paying for the dance see it that way too.

God, that is really disturbing.


Lord of the Rats
Donator V4.0
Rat Boy's picture
Location: Home of the 2010 World Champion San Francisco Giants!

Someone needs to send some giant ogres these guys way. Ones with big clubs and that really don't like paying for anything.

"Men like sex, thus boobies! Oogaba!" - dejanzie

"Butt hat is my opinion and we all know how far that goes around here." - Demonicmaster

Twitter

Server Ninja
Pyroman[FO]'s picture
Location: Lexington, KY

Oh boy, I can't wait to make a human female character, buy a cat, then accept money for cybersex. Except replace "cybersex" with "chat that starts out about sex but goes horribly wrong, ending with vomit". As long as the cyber-pimp doesn't come smack my character up, it'll be glorious.

*edit* Similar to Bloodninja's famous chats

"Use ActiveX — it’s the PBR of client-side web technology." - hipstergrammers
"Try to offer a free dessert to the universe, to truth. You will fail." - Yelping with Cormac

Drawing on the Cave Wall
Donator V7.0
cartoonin99's picture
Location: Logan, UT

Quote:
*edit* Similar to Bloodninja's famous chats

Cripes....I will never look at Land O' Lakes butter the same way again.

Quintin_Stone wrote:

Lunabean, when are you going to grow up and stop playing video games?
lunabean wrote:
After I have sex with your mother.

http://steamcommunity.com/id/cartoonin99

Avant-garde Grognard
Donator V4.0
SwampYankee's picture
Location: Drinking Wine, Eating Cheese, Catching Some Rays

What lonely and consenting ADULTS want to do in the privacy of their own home is not my concern, even when it reaches into the games I play as long as I don't have to see or hear it.

I feel the same way about lonely ugly fat dudes paying a stripper for a handjob in the VIP booths. As long as they're consenting and no one gets hurt and I don't have to see it who freaking cares. Both the guys and the girls are sad and pathetic, but there are all sorts of tired and lonley forsaken souls out there. Let them get their comforts and their joys where they can if it gets them through the day.

What does disgust and enrage me is that some 14 year old girl might think joining an all girl-cat clan is fun and get exposed to this sh*t. Another piece of her innocence and childhood torn away for no damn reason. That makes me mad.

Puttin' on the foil, Coach!
Donator V6.0
Mixolyde's picture
Location: DC Metro, Orange Line, staring at my DS.

Quote:
I had nothing better to do than poke the bear.

Is that code for something?

Great article Ducki!

XBL
Gravey wrote:

This looks sarcastic. I can tell from some of the words and from reading quite a few sarcasms in my time.

Greenwich Mean Gamer
Donator
1Dgaf's picture

"I decided I would log in an unguilded character I had never played and thus would be painless to delete"

I read that as 'pantless'. Hee hee!

PIE MASTER
fangblackbone's picture
Location: bay area

Not to divert attention but Hoochies post started a massive brainstorm for me that I have posted in the MMO forums.

With that said, the human female paladin in war paint armor, even with the guild tabard is perverted. Case in point, jump in the water and start swimming. I am almost disturbed enough to either refuse to go in the water or just move the camera to first person. I really dont need to get a gyrating panty shot of my character, thank you.

Look, Im a guy and I enjoy gyrating panty shots as much as the next guy. I guess it just goes back to the fact that it takes me out of the respect I have for my character that is a large part my alter ego.

Being fangoriously devoured by a gelatinous monster.

Maximus Nofunicus
Donator V8.0
Grumpicus's picture
Location: Despite all my rage, I am still just a rat in a cage.

Hmm. So much to comment on.

As a father to two girls of my own, I completely second what Swampy said.

Pyro's post makes me think of this entry at bash.org... (edit: nevermind, the page he links to is the same thing.)

This comment may be more appropriate for the post in the MMO forums that I haven't looked at yet but will very soon but... While I personally fall under the "my character is a puppet, not an extension of me" camp (though how I handle my puppet and what I make it do obviously reflects to some extent on myself) and therefore don't really care if it's male or female, Fang, you say that your character is a large part of your alter ego. I think that if I felt that way, I'd have more of a problem playing a female character.