Internet Revolts

MMMMAGGOTS!
Donator
nsmike's picture
Location: Pennsylvania

What do people think of the new trend of Internet revolts?

The Digg revolt over the HD DVD key, Anonymous Vs. Scientology, etc. At least every other week, someone shares a tidbit on a site like Digg or reddit that leads a bunch of those users to lead a charge against the guilty party.

Is this new form of mob justice appropriate?

XBL: NSMike | Steam | PSN: NSMike | Wii Friend Code: 7763 1519 2475 2278 | GWJ Google Calendar

Intern
TinPeregrinus's picture
Location: Connecticut

I guess I object to calling it "mob justice." It seems to me that these movements are a constructive result of the free flow of information. I think the news aggregators have increased the efficiency of the spread of information (and of course misinformation) so greatly that they may actually make up for the decline of authoritative news sources like newspapers. If it's misinformation that's being spread, though, I think the likelihood is high that the natural human desire for truth in such cases will win out. The success of Snopes.com is probably the best evidence of that.

That's in this country, of course; when and where the state controls that flow, mileage will vary considerably.

ou gar dokein aristos, all' einai thelei
http://livingepic.blogspot.com: where Classics and gaming meet

Shortbus Commando
Donator
Pharacon's picture
Location: Deep in the heart of Texas... Houston that is...

Its more like consumers arming themselves. Check out the whole creative driver issue that is going on


Xfire: Pharacon
Tempest says: "A team hat doe snot communicate and talk to each other about what the next move will be is going to lose."
Mex is my hero = "f*ck it, I'll do it. WE'LL DO IT LIVE."

MMMMAGGOTS!
Donator
nsmike's picture
Location: Pennsylvania

Pharacon wrote:
Its more like consumers arming themselves. Check out the whole creative driver issue that is going on

Actually, the Creative issue is a good example of mob justice with a negative connotation. Even if it's not popular with the customers, Creative has the right to ask the man making this software, if he did indeed infringe on their IP, to stop. The customers may not like it, and Creative could've handled it entirely differently, but the path they chose is certainly open to them.

XBL: NSMike | Steam | PSN: NSMike | Wii Friend Code: 7763 1519 2475 2278 | GWJ Google Calendar

Claw Shrimp
Donator V4.0
LobsterMobster's picture
Location: On a picnic, going "Ho ho ho!"

TinPeregrinus wrote:
I guess I object to calling it "mob justice." It seems to me that these movements are a constructive result of the free flow of information. I think the news aggregators have increased the efficiency of the spread of information (and of course misinformation) so greatly that they may actually make up for the decline of authoritative news sources like newspapers. If it's misinformation that's being spread, though, I think the likelihood is high that the natural human desire for truth in such cases will win out. The success of Snopes.com is probably the best evidence of that.

That's in this country, of course; when and where the state controls that flow, mileage will vary considerably.

I guess I object to calling it "constructive." Do these "revolts" ever lead to anything?

NOTE: This is not a doodle bug.

Spore

Chainsaw Queen
Donator V2.0
Mystic Violet's picture
Location: San Diego, CA

LobsterMobster wrote:
I guess I object to calling it "constructive." Do these "revolts" ever lead to anything?

Yes, sometimes they do. Digg users were able to find this thief in less than a day. They posted his full name, address, youtube, email, facebook, myspace, AIM, Parent's names, girlfriend's name, home phone, cell phone, girlfriend's phone, etc. He was basically harassed non-stop until he returned the stolen items.

Butt Flaming Follows
Donator V2.0
MoonDragon's picture
Location: Burlington, Canada

Sony rootkit (repeated) debacle(s) was another example.

(@)

Office Linebacker
Raven's picture
Location: Wherever life takes me.

nsmike wrote:
Pharacon wrote:
Its more like consumers arming themselves. Check out the whole creative driver issue that is going on

Actually, the Creative issue is a good example of mob justice with a negative connotation. Even if it's not popular with the customers, Creative has the right to ask the man making this software, if he did indeed infringe on their IP, to stop. The customers may not like it, and Creative could've handled it entirely differently, but the path they chose is certainly open to them.

That's all well and true, Creative does in fact have the right to distribute purposely sub-par drivers and then threaten anyone who fixes their broken code. That being said I would hardly call calling Creative out on this to be "negative". They distributed bad drivers, a modder fixed them, they threatened, people have boycotted Creative.

They've got the right to their IP, we've got the right to not purchase if they're dicks about it. Simple free market in action.

"What exactly is a squirrel licking beta grabbing frump digger?" ~trichy

"Grass grows, birds fly, sun shines and brudda.... I hurt people"

Suck My Diction
dhelor's picture
Location: Oregon

"Sir, the internets are revolting!"

"You said it. They stink on ice."

"I'm absolutely retarded. Not 100% sure why." - atom
"Dhelor + intarwebs = Great ideas." - wordsmythe
"Do I what I do: hate everyone." - Quintin_Stone