I think we tried starting a thread during the first season.

I've been watching the show off and one since it started and I'm caught up to the 7th show in the third season, and, I have to say I also heart Supernatural.

One thing I love about this show is that it takes the standard Scooby Doo format of ghost hunting and puts enough testosterone in it to always satisfy my ego-driven hyper-machismo.

So rarely does a show come along where I think the two young male actors are complete badasses, but this show does it every time.

I wish I had a Dean Winchester trapper keeper.

I am a bit behind on the latest season but if you loved the 1st you are in for a real treat with the second season.

Its one of those shows that may not be the end all and be all of television but it is entertaining. The chemistry between the brothers and later the regular guest stars is perfect. Along with the cool factor of all the shows based on urban legends and campfire ghost stories makes me come back time and time again. The main plot for season two and the ending for lack of a better word was awesome.

and sorry it is better than buffy but that's my opinion

Oh and who can say the music arrangement for the show is anything short of perfect?

well I have to say I totally disagree, and I think your totally wrong with that comment,

Honestly it's one of the shows I really enjoy, there's just something about it but it does remind me alot of buffy and the x-files though, I think it's a great show that's especially hitting it's stride in the second and third seasons.

Originality is overrated.

Don't panic! So far, the said hot chicks are definitely not on the team. Both have caused at least as much grief to the Winchesters as they have prevented. I was worried when I heard about it, but so far it's all good.

My wife and I have been with the show since the first episode, and it is one of the few shows that we rush to the DVR to watch. I love the chemistry between the brothers. There is enough bickering and smart-assery to make you believe that they really are brothers. I'll admit that it's far from the greatest writing, but it is solid enough and entertaining enough to make the show quite enjoyable. As it's been said, the show's take on urban legends and classic movie monsters is well done, even if it's not exactly original. The current season features an episode that deals with the seven deadly sins that was a lot of fun. If you liked the first season, I think you will be quite pleased with what follows.

Oh, and count me in as a big fan of the soundtrack. I lurves me some classic rock.

Yeah, evil kids are just plain creepy.

I too love this show (btw is the show in its Hiatus stage right now for the winter or something?) I esp. love the eps. where Six (cylon from BSG) was in it. That one was very moving and made me weep like a little girl

The only thing I know about Supernatural is that there's a ginormous amount of slashfic about the brothers. (shudder) Bad Internet! Bad!

I was commenting about your comment(s)... wasn't intended as a personal attack. A smiley would have been appropriate.

good to hear. I guess I'll try and track down the season 2 set after finishing season one in the next week or two. Just out of curiosity, has there been any shift in tone or quality since the show moved networks?

Well, you know the TV/Movie writers are on strike, right?

Yeah, that's is very scary. Never understood the appeal or why so many women seem to enjoy this kind of thing.

Your comment's scope went beyond my reply in this thread, and into a condescending reflection on my implied "posting habits". It is clearly implied that said "habits" influence my posting rather than me addressing each post on its own merits, and thus my opinion carries little value - your retroactively applied smiley face nonwithstanding.

I really wish people would stop doing that, or at least have the decency to drop it when it is pointed out to them.

Move along, thread... nothing to see here.

I too am a fan of Supernatural. I don't get a chance to watch it on TV, but have watched the first two seasons via Netflix. Very cool episodic thing going on with a slow-widening of the world in which the two protagonists live (finding out more about their own kind, etc). I look forward to season 3 when it finally appears on DVD. I enjoy the campiness of it as well as the fact it seems very loosely based off of the old WoD roleplaying game, Hunter: The Reckoning.

I admit I shouldn't have "generalized," as long as you'll admit that posting a rather glibly dismissive comment in a loverade thread is going to come off as somewhat abrasive. You might feel you're only "commenting on the show," but it didn't come off that way. Did I dismiss your opinion? Not sure. I know you're an articulate person, yet that initial post didn't seem to have much to say beyond "it sucks."

I compared it to the first season of Buffy. Your praise of the show amounted mostly to it "having two dudes in the main roles", and being "creepy" and "cool". Face it, we're on pretty even ground when it comes to being articulate there. You may see my negativity as unreasonably dismissive just as I may see your positivity as, let's just say... unwarranted.

In the end it is a difference of opinion and everything would've been just fine if you've let it remain that instead of trying to find fault with the way I express mine. It's still not too late to stop, you know.