Tabula Rasa - beta journal

Office Linebacker
Geck's picture
Location: Lost. Drifting.

Apparently the closed beta NDA has been lowered a bit for press, and this blogger shares his early impressions.

No spectacular revelations for those who've been following this title, but it's interesting to hear somebody's take on this who's actually played it.

Gameplay seems to be tactical FPS, but stats-driven. This appeals to me, my ageing twitch reflexes will never be able to keep up with an overcaffeinated 15 year old, but I enjoy tactical gameplay a lot, and TR seems to cater to that.

Despite the fact that news about TR seem to be overshadowed by the WAR and AoC buzz, I am hopeful for TR, and really want this to succeed. A decent Sci Fi MMORPG would be a breath of fresh air among the increasingly cluttered Fantasy MMO WoW clones, and, well, it's Richard Garriot, and I will give anything he produces the benefit of doubt at the very least.

Update: Here's another preview on warcry.

Intern
Shrike's picture

This game is high on my anticipation list, I think/hope it'll be the perfect MMO game for me.

uncapitalized
Donator
ranalin's picture
Location: Knoxville, TN

lineage in space

Gamer Tag: Rantyr

Office Linebacker
Donator
maxox's picture
Location: FL

That read like a pretty bad review to me. He says it is not worth $14.99/month. I'd be interested to know if other testers agree with this. Hypothetically speaking of course.

PIE MASTER
fangblackbone's picture
Location: bay area

I agree with his points. I dont agree with his conclusion or suggestions for pricing. (pay by the hour? gimme a break)

Being fangoriously devoured by a gelatinous monster.

uncapitalized
Donator
ranalin's picture
Location: Knoxville, TN

It's not worth 14.99/month. The ability to shoot in an MMO is a great thing. TR even makes it look FPS'ish. The ability to clone your character at different points makes the ability to roll up an alt that much easier is also a very cool concept that they've brought to the table. Beyond that they have the standard NCsoft skill tree that requires you to grind your way up to get to specific abilities. Once you're maxed out which could be a real quick trip compared to other MMO's then what? End of the day you will realize you've done this before but using a sword/bow.

Gamer Tag: Rantyr

Bilge Cat
Donator V2.0
Farscry's picture
Location: Commanding at the Helm

ranalin wrote:
Once you're maxed out which could be a real quick trip compared to other MMO's then what? End of the day you will realize you've done this before but using a sword/bow.

I see that point a lot, but really, the same can be said of most every game out there. They're all variations on games that have come before them. Be it an mmo, or a fighting game, or an fps, or a sports title, or whatever; usually a game's only real claim to "newness" is some kind of twist or gimmick. In TR's case, it's to combine mmo gameplay with fps gameplay in this fashion.

I see your point, but it's more a point directable at the entire gaming industry/hobby, not just mmo's.

PIE MASTER
fangblackbone's picture
Location: bay area

It is really tactical. Cover works (well!) and you can target body parts on the bigger enemies. The logo powers are fun too.

Being fangoriously devoured by a gelatinous monster.

We won't need roads.
Donator
Aetius's picture

ranalin wrote:
Once you're maxed out which could be a real quick trip compared to other MMO's then what? End of the day you will realize you've done this before but using a sword/bow.

I played DAoC for years after making level 50 (I actually had three level 50 characters higher than RR5). You know, some games actually have content after the grinding. If, as I suspect, a good portion of this game takes place in the end-game, I'm all for that. I'm completely uninterested in grinding levels - the faster it goes, the better.

Remember: this conversation is just between you and me ... and the NSA.
MaverickDago wrote:

Only commies pee "urine" or the devils cocktail as we call it, real Americans exude cold crisp light beer.

uncapitalized
Donator
ranalin's picture
Location: Knoxville, TN

Aetius wrote:
ranalin wrote:
Once you're maxed out which could be a real quick trip compared to other MMO's then what? End of the day you will realize you've done this before but using a sword/bow.

I played DAoC for years after making level 50 (I actually had three level 50 characters higher than RR5). You know, some games actually have content after the grinding. If, as I suspect, a good portion of this game takes place in the end-game, I'm all for that. I'm completely uninterested in grinding levels - the faster it goes, the better.

Well so far they haven't made it known what that content would be in TR. The actual grinding part is engaging, but it's nothing new like they originally told us it'd be.

Fang: ya the logo's system is actually a cool bit!

Honestly i'd be really interested in seeing what the game was like before they scratched it and started over. As it is now you have some very cool design pieces out there but they dont seem completely fleshed out and personally it looks like they just draped those over a NCsoft shell.

Gamer Tag: Rantyr

Consultant
Donator
mven's picture

I am not sure how far down the NDA has gone but I will give the simplest description of my experience with TR beta I can think of. If you played SWG post NGE it feels almost exactly the same except that you can just shoot at the ground if you don't have a target and want to fire off some shots (which I am not sure if you could do in SWG). I didn't really stick with it long enough to know how the game plays out higher end.

What's a Tag?

I'm in the beta. Anymore said than that and I'd have to kill ya. But I know they won't get mad if I pimp the game and I do will do so because LOrd British gave me that great Ultima III experience.

The atmosphere is sweet and the fps-ish combat is too even if it's still stat based.

Executive
armedbushido's picture
Location: Das Bunker

For me TR has been just plain fun and have not felt the wait on my shoulders of leveling like most of the MMO's I have played. However, more testing is needed...

uncapitalized
Donator
ranalin's picture
Location: Knoxville, TN

i dont think this will break current NDA.

I was curious of everyones level that's currently still in Beta.

Gamer Tag: Rantyr

Executive
armedbushido's picture
Location: Das Bunker
0 to Zen in under 6 seconds
Donator V4.0
karmajay's picture
Location: St. Pete, Florida

Quote:
For those interested; http://www.fileplanet.com/promotions/tab...asa/

You have to be a fileplanet subscriber to be part of that fyi.

I don't think I've ever said this sentence before, but man would I love to hump that butterfly.-- KrazyTaco
One phone call and you're melting like butter over my kettle pop. -- Edwin to Mex
2005 GWJFFL2 Champion

PIE MASTER
fangblackbone's picture
Location: bay area

I think the beta keys are all grabbed up. I tried to sign up and it tells me that my system doesn't meet the requirements without even asking me for them.

edit: NM gotta use internet explorer... blech

Being fangoriously devoured by a gelatinous monster.

I Can Has Manga?
Donator V2.0
AnimeJ's picture
Location: The skies of Norkia

fangblackbone wrote:
I think the beta keys are all grabbed up. I tried to sign up and it tells me that my system doesn't meet the requirements without even asking me for them.

edit: NM gotta use internet explorer... blech

I didn't use IE when I signed up.

Coldstream wrote:

Sands, S. & Murdoch, J.; New England Journal of Medicine. Why Guys Dig Chicks Who Kill Violently Kill Stuff Nov, 2008; pp 65-68.

GWJ Recruiter
Donator V3.0
Flux's picture
Location: Dirty South

I got into the beta barely last night, looking forward to trying it out in 2 days.

Xbox Live: Kooter06

Marks The Spot
Donator V3.0
Elliottx's picture
Location: Vancouver, WA, USA, Earth, Milky Way

I may have just received an email regarding a beta invitation.

XBL: elliottxW
MMO Aliases: Jozak or Ezzamar

PIE MASTER
fangblackbone's picture
Location: bay area

If I were in, I would be thoroughly enjoying it

Being fangoriously devoured by a gelatinous monster.

All your sietch are belong to us
Donator V4.0
Fedaykin98's picture
Location: Houston, TX

If you were in, that would be good news!

Quote:

Would be a good idea. I plan to have Logan sit in for me when I am on my honeymoon.

- Legion, taking "keeping it in the family" to a whole new level.

Xbox Live: Fedaykin98

0 to Zen in under 6 seconds
Donator V4.0
karmajay's picture
Location: St. Pete, Florida

Quote:
I may have just received an email regarding a beta invitation.

Ended up just being a pre order email, eh?

I don't think I've ever said this sentence before, but man would I love to hump that butterfly.-- KrazyTaco
One phone call and you're melting like butter over my kettle pop. -- Edwin to Mex
2005 GWJFFL2 Champion

We won't need roads.
Donator
Aetius's picture

Pre-Order packs are available. They list beta access as part of the pre-order, but the access isn't active yet. I bought one and downloaded the client last night (it was 2GB). And in a very smart move, the pre-order pack is $5.

Remember: this conversation is just between you and me ... and the NSA.
MaverickDago wrote:

Only commies pee "urine" or the devils cocktail as we call it, real Americans exude cold crisp light beer.

Coffee Grinder

This is my first post on the GWJ forums, hurrah!

Anyway, I mostly agree with what's been said thus far. It's nice to see something different, I'm just not sure it's got what it takes to stay interesting.

The Wizahd
Donator V3.0
Brizahd's picture
Location: not sure

I got the preorder e-mail and I'm very tempted to go ahead and do it.

Doooom!
Donator V6.0
Strekos's picture
Location: Dripping Springs, TX

Played over the weekend via Fileplanet, got to level 7, and I wish we could discuss it here. Hopefully the NDA gets dropped for beta players soon.

WAR: Coda, Archmage, Vortex <Unguilded>

PIE MASTER
fangblackbone's picture
Location: bay area

^^ Agreed

Being fangoriously devoured by a gelatinous monster.

0 to Zen in under 6 seconds
Donator V4.0
karmajay's picture
Location: St. Pete, Florida

Quote:
And in a very smart move, the pre-order pack is $5

Like a store pre-order can you NOT go back and pay the remainder because you didn't like the game, etc?

I don't think I've ever said this sentence before, but man would I love to hump that butterfly.-- KrazyTaco
One phone call and you're melting like butter over my kettle pop. -- Edwin to Mex
2005 GWJFFL2 Champion

We won't need roads.
Donator
Aetius's picture

karmajay wrote:
Quote:
And in a very smart move, the pre-order pack is $5

Like a store pre-order can you NOT go back and pay the remainder because you didn't like the game, etc?

The only restriction I am aware of is that if you bought the pre-order in the store, *if* you want to buy the game you need to buy the retail copy. Similarly, if you bought online, *if* you want the full game, you need to buy online. I think there is also a U.S./European distinction as well. There is no requirement or obligation to purchase the full game AFAIK.

Remember: this conversation is just between you and me ... and the NSA.
MaverickDago wrote:

Only commies pee "urine" or the devils cocktail as we call it, real Americans exude cold crisp light beer.

uncapitalized
Donator
ranalin's picture
Location: Knoxville, TN

i jumped back in last night and have another complaint for the game. I'm level 20 and have absolutely no clue where to go next. Anyone else have any ideas.

Gamer Tag: Rantyr