Advice on a portable navigation/gps system
Monday, November 20th, 2006 - 5:21pm
I am in the market for a portable navigation system. The models I am considering are:
Garmin Nuvi 600/350
TomTom 910/510
Does anyone own either of these or anything else and have any words of wisdom?
Thanks!
Oh crumbs, I'm all thumbs laying here with you. You're beautiful and busty and I'm a little rusty - I've forgotten what to do...



Make sure that you budget for the maps you actually want. I don't know those systems but my Garmin out of the box had very little I could actually use and the maps I did want cost a lot extra.
You can't make somebody love you, but you can buy a bigger television.
I bought the Lowrance 350 last year before I moved to L.A. and it was a great decision. Right out of the box it was fully up to date. It has the nifty extra feature of being a MP3 player with FM transmitter built in with a standard SD drive as storage. I've had 2 problems with it that may or may not be specific to the brand/model.
1. When first booting it can take 5 to 10 minutes to sync with the satellites. This may be because I have to park underground just about everywhere I go. Almost nowhere has above ground parking here so its hard to tell if that's a factor or not.
2. Heat. I parked my car on the top level of a parking garage one day and it got quite hot. The windows were up and the GPS unit was stored in one of the consoles. The battery seems to have been fried and there may have been some damage to the FM transmitter because it just doesn't sound very good anymore. The unit still runs when fed power directly so there's really no change in the way I use it but permanant damage to a $400 piece of hardware makes me unhappy. Thankfully the screen and touch-sensing are still perfect.
ThePolypusher
GH3 Stats
I thought they all came with an full and updated map of the U.S. Which maps did it give you?
Currently on a gaming hiatus until the fall.
This was two years ago, things may have changed. I got a very large-scale (as in not detailed) map of the U.S. The two things I was looking for, detailed city maps and topos of national parks, were both add-ons.
You can't make somebody love you, but you can buy a bigger television.
It's nice to have a model that pronounces street names instead of just "Turn LEFT" and "Turn RIGHT". Garmin has one for <$400 .
I have Garmin Nuvi 350. There's a newer model 360 which includes a bult-in Bluetooth handsfree, and now a step-up model 660 that is basically 360, but with a wide screen and TMC real-time traffic antenna bundled in.
I am very happy with my unit. It has maps for the entire North America. The maps haven't failed me once. The unit does have text-to-speech prompts mentioned by Shiho. It's of a tremendous convenience and works, as much as I'd want to avoid absolutes, just flawlessly.
350's strength is in traveling. It's not as beefy in POIs handling. There're millions of them, but they're service and travel oriented. Some users complain that it doesn't have every BestBuy or WalMart and stuff. But you can import your own POIs.
Garmin does listen to their users and updates the software frequently. You can buy updated maps for USA (refreshed every 2 years or so), as well as for Europe (whole or piece-meal countries). There's also a nice Travel Guide software supplied by Fodor's.
The satellite lock-on works happens fast, well under a minute in any conditions, and keeps on tight. Typical precision it reports is 16 feet.
The bes testament I can give to the 350's reliability, robustness, and ease of use is that I let my wife drive with her mom on a sightseeing trip from NJ to Washington D.C armed with just Nuvi 350 plus Travel Guide (well, and my wife's martial arts skills).
Xbox Live tag Gorilla800lbs
Another vote for the Garmin Nuvi. I've had the 360 for a few months now and it is great. The Bluetooth connectivity with my phone is really cool and is something I use often. My job requires to travel alot and use the phone so this kills two birds with one stone. You can get the 360 now for under $600.
Is the screen on the Nuvi 360 big enough? I mean in relative terms.
The biggest points made is that Garmin seems to have better satellite technology and a more rich POI database that comes standard. I've heard mixed reviews of the Bluetooth capability, TomTom gets marks for having only slightly better sound. Both are regarded as having pretty crappy sound, in general. This tends to make me want to steer clear of the TomTom 910 with MP3 player built in.
I have also heard that Garmin has a far better glare filter on the unit which makes them easier to read in sunlight.
Thanks for the help, folks. I'm starting to narrow my search.
Oh crumbs, I'm all thumbs laying here with you. You're beautiful and busty and I'm a little rusty - I've forgotten what to do...
I'd like to get one with a big screen and one that is very detailed. Is Garmin the way to go?
Currently on a gaming hiatus until the fall.
Bwaaaa hahahahah haha ha!
Mercury's been in retrograde most of the week. It's like a full moon with a side of kicked-in-the-nuts. -- H.P. Lovesauce
Nuvi's sound is excellent. The screen is laid out very well and the screen estate is used well. My only minor gripe is that it doesn't show the lane info line the most cutting edge systems do (Navigon), and doesn't even show the turn icon until you approach the turn. IT does write about it, however, and of course says its out loud.
One thing TomTom is said to do much better is screen image. Whereas Garmin units redraw the whole screen as you move on the map or manually move around it using the controls, the recent TomTom units pan it very fluidly, "just like a videogame".
Xbox Live tag Gorilla800lbs