CPU Cooling: How are you cooling your systems?

Cooling? I use what ever Dell put in it.
3% (1 vote)
Stock HSF from the manufacturer (Intel/AMD)
43% (13 votes)
Third Party HSF
43% (13 votes)
Third Party HS without a Fan. Quiet is king.
0% (0 votes)
Liquid Cooling System: I live on the edge and like it.
10% (3 votes)
Total votes: 30
Finger of God
Donator V3.0
Staats's picture
Location: Minnesota

I'm using a stock fan from AMD. I would not recommend it.

Xbox Live: StaatsM

You Shall Not Pass!
Donator V4.0
CEJ's picture
Location: Southern California

As a point of reference, I had some heat issues a few days ago and found a lot of choices on newegg. Also, found this cool Liquid Cooling System linked through a review on BluesNews.

Poll Legend:
HSF = Heat Sink Fan combo. Example: Thermaltake CL-P0200 Silent 939 K8 (Link)
HS = Heat Sink only. No fan so no noise. Example: Asus Ultra Silent for Ultimate Performance (Link)
Liquid cooling System: Example: Cool Masters AQUAGATE Mini R80/R120 System (Link)

So go ahead and vote and lets see what you all are doing.

Steam Community ID
Mythos Player ID: cejansen

Nine Lives of Doom
PurEvil's picture
Location: Columbia, MD

I'm using a Spire WhisperRock fan. 19dba... very quiet. I was using a stock HSF until recently, and I never realized how loud it was till I put this sucker in my machine.

IronClad Online: PurEvil

they charge per letter
pol's picture
Location: Charlottesville, VA

stock HSF....system is cool and quiet

ymmv however since it seems my situation is quite unique

Head Coach
*Legion*'s picture
Location: Monterey

Random splashes of Evian when I don't feel like finishing off the bottle.

Gaming / PC Tech Blog: Blast Processing - www.blastprocessing.net
Xbox Live: Legion SB | PSN: Legion_SB

"Damn, your comedic timing is awesome." -- Spaz, *Legion* Fan #1437

Off With My Head!
Donator
LiquidMantis's picture
Location: Rocky Mtn. Foothills

Zalman radial coolers are all I use. Nice slow (therefore reliable) and basically silent fan.

Xbox Live: LiquidmantisGWJ | PSN: LiquidmantisGWJ
Web: Mantis on the Mountain
--
My wife liked the man part monster I made. -Pharacon

You Shall Not Pass!
Donator V4.0
CEJ's picture
Location: Southern California

LiquidMantis wrote:
Zalman radial coolers are all I use. Nice slow (therefore reliable) and basically silent fan.

I talked to a buddy of mine before I left for the long weekend. Turns out he dropped an older one of these on my door step. It didn't fit on the board he had purchased. Nice looking fan though.

Steam Community ID
Mythos Player ID: cejansen

Got Death Star?
Lord_Xan's picture
Location: Cape Town, South Africa

Stock Intel for me as well. Even with the hot summers over here I haven't had any problems with it so far.

Swing harder! Swing harder!
-- Lilarcor, Baldur's Gate 2

Feathered Fury
Donator
duckilama's picture
Location: Fighting for Bovine Freedom!

Staats wrote:
I'm using a stock fan from AMD. I would not recommend it.

Me too. No problems.

"And my son, too, thinks everything is a launchpad, every bug a meal, and every sunny day a reason to take all your clothes off and roll around in the grass." - rabbit

Baron Münchhausen
Donator V2.0
rabbit's picture
Location: The Basement

I use a koolance exos water system using nonconductive fluid. Now, while this should be all "ooh what hotness" I will tell you that in retrospect, a few years later, I suffer from a little "what was I thinking" syndrome.

Yes, it works. Yes, it keeps things pretty quiet. However, while it let me OC my vidcard and processor, I soon found out that in order to keep my hard drives and memory cool enough not to cause issues, I needed decent airflow. Add to this the rather significant weight of vid card water systems and you end up with a remarkably fragile setup.

So yes, it works, and yes, I get some OC out of it. But in the end, I think I would have been better off saving the 500 bucks or so and putting it in a bank for upgrades later on in the cycle...

Gamertag: GWJ Rabbit | Last.fm | Twitter

"Think of it as 'grinding SO rep in the Kitchen instance.' " - Montalban

Finger of God
Donator V3.0
Staats's picture
Location: Minnesota

duckilama wrote:
Staats wrote:
I'm using a stock fan from AMD. I would not recommend it.

Me too. No problems.

What chipset? I've got a 3000+ in a well ventilated case, and it runs in the high forties (C) when the AC's on, and will reach up to the low to mid fifties if I really push it.

Next upgrade I'm going ahead and getting a third party fan... they're pretty cheap and I don't have to worry about the temperature.

Xbox Live: StaatsM

*censored*
Donator
doihaveto's picture
Location: SF, CA

I use the stock heatsink from Intel. The Pentium D 9xx series comes with some ridiculously big heat sinks...

Republican Stormtrooper of Doom
Donator V2.0
Pigpen's picture
Location: SA TX

liquid bay beeeeeeeeeee!

"I mean, she likes sex, too, and is quite good at it if you ask me, but it doesn't mean she wants it forced upon her whenever someone decides they want that from her."
Shaderaven discussing AoC PVP...hmmmmmmmmm

Feathered Fury
Donator
duckilama's picture
Location: Fighting for Bovine Freedom!

Staats wrote:
duckilama wrote:
Staats wrote:
I'm using a stock fan from AMD. I would not recommend it.

Me too. No problems.

What chipset? I've got a 3000+ in a well ventilated case, and it runs in the high forties (C) when the AC's on, and will reach up to the low to mid fifties if I really push it.

Next upgrade I'm going ahead and getting a third party fan... they're pretty cheap and I don't have to worry about the temperature.


Socket 754. An old Alienware case with a side fan, one or two front fans, and a back fan in addition to the PSU fan. I'll have to go get MBM again and check my temps, but I recall them being "okay". Not great, not bad, just ok.

"And my son, too, thinks everything is a launchpad, every bug a meal, and every sunny day a reason to take all your clothes off and roll around in the grass." - rabbit

Junior Executive
Donator
Dream's picture
Location: Milwaukee, WI

I'm using a stock fan from AMD, on mine and have no problems granted it is for a4800+ so some things may have changed between your 3000+ Staats. I also have a very good ventilation system going on within my case as well. For one I have a vent on the side of my case that allows the HSF to blow straight out into the room, rather than having the case fans move that air out.

BF2stats
MTGO - TheMentat
BF2 - EElite

they charge per letter
pol's picture
Location: Charlottesville, VA

Quote:
What chipset?

Sorry to butt in but this is really starting to irk me. Seems like there are several people around with similar setups and hugely varying results. Could the case make that much difference? I assume I dont need to ask if people are quoting temps on clean boxes (i.e. dust free)

amd64 3200 socket 939..... 35-40 stock....37-45 @ 2.5 ghz

I really want to buy one of those fancy coolers, just have to figure out a way to make the damn thing hotter

You Shall Not Pass!
Donator V4.0
CEJ's picture
Location: Southern California

pol wrote:
Seems like there are several people around with similar setups and hugely varying results. Could the case make that much difference? I assume I dont need to ask if people are quoting temps on clean boxes (i.e. dust free)

amd64 3200 socket 939..... 35-40 stock....37-45 @ 2.5 ghz

I really want to buy one of those fancy coolers, just have to figure out a way to make the damn thing hotter

Well, here's my configuration:
AMD64 3800 Socket 939 (NForce4 Chipset) in an Antec Sonata II Case

  • With Retail HSF .... 50-68C
  • With 3rd Party Cooler and Antec's Cool Air Duct ... 38-50C
I do think cases make a huge difference. Some just breath better than others. While this is good for OCing your system, its bad for noise and such. About two years ago, I gave up on the whole OC thing and opted for quieter systems instead. I rolled out two shinney new Antec Sonata cases and then just this year, upgraded my whole rig to the new Sonata II case. I will admit that I liked the standard Sonata case better than the new, revised one. I'd rather have two fans vs. the goofy air ducting.

MoBo Chipsets also run hot. My old Soyo board with my AMD 2000 on it always ran hot. Not really sure why, but it did cook the chipset fan which I had to replace.

Steam Community ID
Mythos Player ID: cejansen

Finger of God
Donator V3.0
Staats's picture
Location: Minnesota

pol wrote:
Quote:
What chipset?

Sorry to butt in but this is really starting to irk me. Seems like there are several people around with similar setups and hugely varying results. Could the case make that much difference? I assume I dont need to ask if people are quoting temps on clean boxes (i.e. dust free)

The case I had previous to the one I currently was clean, but ran hot. Really hot. A good day was in the low fifties, and in the summer while gaming a reboot was not uncommon. I eventually had to pop off the side and run a normal fan in there to keep my hardware in order.

After upgrading to a nice CoolerMaster tower, the temps dropped by almost ten degrees. I should have done it years ago.

Xbox Live: StaatsM

You Shall Not Pass!
Donator V4.0
CEJ's picture
Location: Southern California

Just read an interesting review on motherboards.org about liquid cooling and an Evercool WC202 Water Cooling System.

Tultain wrote:
Any enthusiast will tell you one thing and one thing alone about cooling - you'll love it so long as it works. For what it's worth, I loved the simplicity and efficiency of this system. Hell, with its ability to cool a sizzling Prescott system, and the low noise which it did that with, I had no qualms with implementing it in my work machine in weeks to come. This is, of course, where the issues came in.

While it is rare for a product to be physically destroyed here at motherboards.org, you've got to understand just how a certain Editor In Chief above me feels when he trusts and endorsees a product. Then the pump dies, and kills his prize CPU. A gaboffle like that usually results in everything being carefully uninstalled, then hurtled out the window at the highest point of the house - well, you get the picture. If the unit's pump had not died, and the system had lived, I might have recommended it in the review, but with the pump dying, and the unit causing a system fatality - one that was worth around ten times it's value to boot - well, that's just not acceptable.

Not acceptable is being gentle to the product; while DOA units like this are bound to occur in the wild, it should then be the manufacturer's duty to do something like Corsair did back with their Hydrocool. When the pump stopped, or the temperature reached past a point of sanity, the unit would first begin with a painfully loud siren, and finish off by powering down the system. Having been gone at the time, you would just come back, turn on the machine, and be alerted - by that hellishly loud siren - that something was very wrong. Said siren was also loud enough to wake you up if you had been asleep, giving you the time to realize that you'd have to fix things in the morning. Instead of all these things, the Evercool unit just died, and the processor merrily putted along, until it passed on in a plume of magic smoke. As such, I can NOT recommend this until Evercool implements a safety feature (or features) such as the ones outlined here.

Link to the summary fo their review can be found here.

Rabbit, this sort of sounds like what you mentioned about your system, no?

Steam Community ID
Mythos Player ID: cejansen

Feathered Fury
Donator
duckilama's picture
Location: Fighting for Bovine Freedom!

pol wrote:
Quote:
What chipset?

Sorry to butt in but this is really starting to irk me. Seems like there are several people around with similar setups and hugely varying results. Could the case make that much difference? I assume I dont need to ask if people are quoting temps on clean boxes (i.e. dust free)

amd64 3200 socket 939..... 35-40 stock....37-45 @ 2.5 ghz

I really want to buy one of those fancy coolers, just have to figure out a way to make the damn thing hotter


The case makes a big difference, as do the fans you're using, and even cabling can have an impact. The big issue is airflow - you need cool(er) air coming into the case and the hot(ter) air being pushed/pulled out. If you have blockages or just a case that doesn't let enough air in(or out) or maybe you've got _all_ your fans pointing in instead of some in and some out(airflow) then you won't get as good results as someone who's made it a point to arrange things well. If you just have fans that are simply stirring up the warm air inside the case, it's gonna be hot.

Anyway, I've got a Chaintech VNF3-250 (socket 754) and a Sempron 3100+, 2 HDs in the bays, a Radeon 9800Pro, a fan on the side/door of the case blowing in, a fan (or is it 2?) on the front blowing in, and a fan on the back blowing out(along with the PSU fan blowing out). There doesn't seem to be much difference with teh door closed or open, but if you're having heat issues, try taking the door/sides off and see if your temps improve. If so, maybe you've got airflow issues.

"And my son, too, thinks everything is a launchpad, every bug a meal, and every sunny day a reason to take all your clothes off and roll around in the grass." - rabbit

You Shall Not Pass!
Donator V4.0
CEJ's picture
Location: Southern California

You can find a how to on cooling your PC Case here.

EDIT: For you my friends, I ventured into the heart of darkness and found the following link with a ton of CPU cooler recommendations.

Steam Community ID
Mythos Player ID: cejansen

they charge per letter
pol's picture
Location: Charlottesville, VA

Quote:
You can find a how to on cooling your PC Case here.

guess I just didnt think case type would make that much difference. my case is the one pictured in your thread there

Executive
Donator V3.0
Chum's picture
Location: Stage left, guitar aflame

I'm using a Thermalright SI-120 - cools well and is extremely quiet with a low RPM 80mm fan. Here's a pic of it mounted on my motherboard (I was swapping out the NB fan at the time).

In my quest for cool and quiet, I also chose the Antec P180 (pic)-- having both the PSU and HDs in a separate compartment with it's own airflow has helped me keep temps extremely low on my OC'd Opteron (idles at 34C).

Xbox Live: Chumtastic

Get Me The Hell Outta Bosnia
el_dino's picture
Location: Sarajevo, Bosnia

My CPU (Barton 2600+ overclocked to 2,2 GHz) cooler is Thermaltake, full copper, nothing fancy. No problems, so far (18 months).

Panem et circenses

"You really need to smoke a tree first to appreciate that one." - Sanjuro

You Shall Not Pass!
Donator V4.0
CEJ's picture
Location: Southern California

Chum wrote:
I'm using a Thermalright SI-120 - cools well and is extremely quiet with a low RPM 80mm fan. Here's a pic of it mounted on my motherboard (I was swapping out the NB fan at the time).

In my quest for cool and quiet, I also chose the Antec P180 (pic)-- having both the PSU and HDs in a separate compartment with it's own airflow has helped me keep temps extremely low on my OC'd Opteron (idles at 34C).

Damn. That P180 is a nice case. Wish I had the budget to purchase one of those.

Steam Community ID
Mythos Player ID: cejansen

Coffee Grinder

CNPS7000B-Cu LED:

It's gigantic, and very heavy but you can't hear it with your ear next to it.

This + Cool & Quiet = You'll never hear it; I'm not even kidding. Sometimes it drops to like 800 RPMs and scares my monitoring software. If you get one for an AMD CPU with Cool'n'Quiet take the speed adjustment thing that comes with it and throw it away. You don't need it.

I was so impressed with quiet/effectiveness I got a zalman graphics card cooler and passive chipset heatsink (after going through two stock ASUS fans.

Off With My Head!
Donator
LiquidMantis's picture
Location: Rocky Mtn. Foothills

Hurray! Another Zalman fan. *ahem*

Ditto on the P180. I've got two at the house and all my new builds at the office are in P180s. It's a slower case to build up but the quality and sound control is worth it.

Xbox Live: LiquidmantisGWJ | PSN: LiquidmantisGWJ
Web: Mantis on the Mountain
--
My wife liked the man part monster I made. -Pharacon

You Shall Not Pass!
Donator V4.0
CEJ's picture
Location: Southern California

Well, I'm still reading some of these water cooling solutions and found a review of the G-Cooler LC478K8 Water Cooling Kit on Reviewdesk.com. As it turns out, the pump failed after just one (1) day (see page 4 of the review. link). That's pretty hedious. I'd steer clear of this one.

Steam Community ID
Mythos Player ID: cejansen

Its good to be the Koning
Koning_Floris's picture
Location: gamerswithjobs.com

I got the new stock cooler from AMD with my 4400+ wich does its job very well.

I don't watch, I interact!

Baron Münchhausen
Donator V2.0
rabbit's picture
Location: The Basement

CEJ: I've been very happy with my Koolance Exos stuff. I don't OC, I just like it quiet. Temps stay quite low. I've never really been able to succesfully OC, but its not because of the temps, I'm quite sure of that. I just always end up buying out at the edge of performance when I upgrade, and there's usually not much OC room.

But the exos is great, flexible, and a good bargain.

Gamertag: GWJ Rabbit | Last.fm | Twitter

"Think of it as 'grinding SO rep in the Kitchen instance.' " - Montalban