Boardgames -- Any recommendations?

Your Favorite Game is Dumb
SommerMatt's picture
Location: Racine, WI

So while I was at TOYS R US looking for something to use my 20% off coupon, i noticed that they are stocking a bunch of really interesting board games there now, aside from the usualy Hasbro/Milton Bradley stuff.

So a few games I saw there--

1. Carcassonne

2. Ticket to Ride

3. Risk: Godstorm

There might have been a few others, but I can't remember any of them. I have also long heard great things about "Settlers of Cataan" too, but they didn't have any of those... I'm in the market for a 2 player game that I can convince my GF to play, so anyone have any reviews/comments or criticisms of any of the above games?

I know there are a few threads for months back where people were talking about board games, but I figure enough time has passed to bring it back...

xbox LIVE: NatsuMatto
PSN: SommerMatt
That's What She Said -- A Podcast About NBC's THE OFFICE
Twitter: SommerMatt

Ec0n Major
Donator V3.0
Ulairi's picture
Location: Is right behind you!

Do you know where any game stores (non video) are? Settles is a fantastic game to get gf/kids/older people to play. I mean it isn't like TITAN! which scares away people.

Your Favorite Game is Dumb
SommerMatt's picture
Location: Racine, WI

Quote:
Do you know where any game stores (non video) are? Settles is a fantastic game to get gf/kids/older people to play. I mean it isn't like TITAN! which scares away people.

Are you asking me seriously? You're in Brookfield, right? The biggest/best boardgame store I know in Milwaukee is called NAPOLEON'S, which is a few blocks east of Oakland avenue on Capital Drive. Or were you just asking me because you were going to fill me in?

Despite being an RPG/Game geek, I have never played Settlers or any other board games like this aside from the awesome FORMULA DE.

xbox LIVE: NatsuMatto
PSN: SommerMatt
That's What She Said -- A Podcast About NBC's THE OFFICE
Twitter: SommerMatt

Puttin' on the foil, Coach!
Donator V5.0
Mixolyde's picture
Location: Usually an ice rink in Newark, DE

Carcassonne is a great game for two players, but it's better with more. If you're looking for some good cheap games, try http://www.cheapass.com You can get great games at great prices and then use your coupon for video games

XBL
Jonman wrote:

Bullion Cube wrote:
Looks like a more frenetic God of War...for perverts.

*places pre-order*

Your Favorite Game is Dumb
SommerMatt's picture
Location: Racine, WI

Quote:
try http://www.cheapass.com

I used to see these guys at GenCon all the time, but I got the impression that their games were pretty quick beer & pretzel affairs that didn't really hold up to long term play. I guess I'm really looking for a game for 2 players... I dont think I am ever going to get more than my GF and myself to play any of these. So Carcassonne is good?

xbox LIVE: NatsuMatto
PSN: SommerMatt
That's What She Said -- A Podcast About NBC's THE OFFICE
Twitter: SommerMatt

Drowned the Scorpion
Donator
SlyFrog's picture
Location: Amphibious Sanctuary

Quote:
I used to see these guys at GenCon all the time, but I got the impression that their games were pretty quick beer & pretzel affairs that didn't really hold up to long term play. I guess I'm really looking for a game for 2 players... I dont think I am ever going to get more than my GF and myself to play any of these. So Carcassonne is good?

It is very well liked by most people who have played it (at least that is my finding).

Ec0n Major
Donator V3.0
Ulairi's picture
Location: Is right behind you!

Quote:
Are you asking me seriously? You're in Brookfield, right? The biggest/best boardgame store I know in Milwaukee is called NAPOLEON'S, which is a few blocks east of Oakland avenue on Capital Drive. Or were you just asking me because you were going to fill me in?

Napoleon's is no longer in business. The best place in Milwaukee is now Adventure Games Plus (www.agpweb.com). I don't think Settlers can be found anywhere other than a game store.

Your Favorite Game is Dumb
SommerMatt's picture
Location: Racine, WI

Quote:
Napoleon's is no longer in business. The best place in Milwaukee is now Adventure Games Plus (www.agpweb.com). I don't think Settlers can be found anywhere other than a game store.

Man... I havent been there in a while, and now I guess I don't have to! I think I've been to the AGP store before... But for something like that, I'd more likely just order it online.

xbox LIVE: NatsuMatto
PSN: SommerMatt
That's What She Said -- A Podcast About NBC's THE OFFICE
Twitter: SommerMatt

Old Vet
Donator V6.0
Donan's picture
Location: PNW

Risk 2210

Risk: Lord of the Rings, Triology Edition

Battle Cry

Reiner Knizia's Samurai

Napoleon in Europe (Eagle Games)

The American Civil War (Eagle Games)

Attack (Eagle Games).

Napoleonic Wars (GMT Games)

Star Wars Duels (Milton Bradely)

Samurai Swords (MB).

Check out Funagain Games for some good on-line ordering deals. Very reputable.

Also, if you want more of a hardcore wargames, let me know (check out GMT Games
and HPS Simulations, and others.

XBL:DonanGWJ
PSN: Toxdon

Puttin' on the foil, Coach!
Donator V5.0
Mixolyde's picture
Location: Usually an ice rink in Newark, DE

SommerMatt wrote:
Quote:
try http://www.cheapass.com

I used to see these guys at GenCon all the time, but I got the impression that their games were pretty quick beer & pretzel affairs that didn't really hold up to long term play.

I've been playing some of these games off and on for about 6 years now. Some of them really do hold up, particularly Starbase Jeff and Give me the Brain. The Very Clever Pipe game is an excellent two player game from them and requires no extra parts. I'd highly recommend The Works if you can find it based on Phill Foglio's Girl Genuis comic. And Blink for fast, simple fun. Hard to find good two players games, but they're out there. There are a couple of two player card games from the Catan people, but I don't know if they're any good.

Also, definitely check out http://www.boardgamegeek.com/ !!!

XBL
Jonman wrote:

Bullion Cube wrote:
Looks like a more frenetic God of War...for perverts.

*places pre-order*

Skill Tree of Life
Donator V2.0
Sephirotic's picture
Location: The Ravenous Spark

Even my wife likes Carcassonne, but it is better with more players. She's even a fan of some of the cheap-ass games. "lord of the fries" gets played frequently. I second Board Game Geek as a good, overall reference and rating system.

AND, if you wait about 2 months, I will be sending out PDF's of my new boardgame for focus and beta testing.

Sephirotic | I am your future...swallowed up in fire | PSN: Sephirotic

Your Favorite Game is Dumb
SommerMatt's picture
Location: Racine, WI

Quote:
AND, if you wait about 2 months, I will be sending out PDF's of my new boardgame for focus and beta testing.

wow, never knew I was in the presence of such greatness

xbox LIVE: NatsuMatto
PSN: SommerMatt
That's What She Said -- A Podcast About NBC's THE OFFICE
Twitter: SommerMatt

Your Favorite Game is Dumb
SommerMatt's picture
Location: Racine, WI

So has anyone played TICKET TO RIDE?

xbox LIVE: NatsuMatto
PSN: SommerMatt
That's What She Said -- A Podcast About NBC's THE OFFICE
Twitter: SommerMatt

I Got Better!
Donator V5.0
Edgar_Newt's picture
Location: Pacific Palisades, CA

I am a board game geek, but I have only played Carcassonne once. No real desire to purchase it to play it again. Two person games are tough, once you get past Cribbage.

I recommend BoardGameGeek.com for reviews and fairplay.com (which I now use almost exclusively -- I find they have better prices than funagain.com). I used to purchase from funagain (they are reliable and prompt), but now prefer fairplay. Their website is not as professional as funagain, but they make up for it in lower prices (at least for what I have purchased) and prompt shipping.

For a multiplayer board game, I recommend Power Grid. Interesting mechanics and some nuanced game play.

Gamer Tag -- Edgar Newt

Mr. GOH wrote:

"...the majority of evil organizations should wear their lawyers' guts for garters if the lawyers don't urge incorporation!"

Puttin' on the foil, Coach!
Donator V5.0
Mixolyde's picture
Location: Usually an ice rink in Newark, DE

I highly recommend any *rails game for two players. Particularly Euro Rails and Empire Builder. Any more than 4 players slows the game down way too much. 2 players moves along pretty well.

BGG gave Ticket to Ride a pretty high rating and some good reviews. http://www.boardgamegeek.com/game/9209

XBL
Jonman wrote:

Bullion Cube wrote:
Looks like a more frenetic God of War...for perverts.

*places pre-order*

Coffee Grinder

SommerMatt wrote:
So has anyone played TICKET TO RIDE?

I own Ticket to Ride and enjoy it quite a bit. It's my wife's current favorite. A good amount of strategy, with minimum luck factor. Gameplay is very simple but with lots of agonizing decisions. Game components are excellent (Days of Wonder puts together some very nice games with top-notch components -- other excellent ones from that publisher are Memoir '44 and Pirate's Cove)

Someone mentioned boardgamegeek.com. It's an excellent site for game research.

Skill Tree of Life
Donator V2.0
Sephirotic's picture
Location: The Ravenous Spark

SommerMatt wrote:

wow, never knew I was in the presence of such greatness

Hardly I just like making games. It's why I ended up where I did. There's a dude at Blizzard North, Steve Lebrand I think is his name, that makes a new boardgame every week. The kicker? they are all achingly fun. After playing a couple of them, it inspired me to make my own. Word so far is that it's pretty fun, but it is EARLY in development.

Sephirotic | I am your future...swallowed up in fire | PSN: Sephirotic

Puttin' on the foil, Coach!
Donator V5.0
Mixolyde's picture
Location: Usually an ice rink in Newark, DE

Here's a pretty decent list of two-player games from a fairly cheap dealer http://thoughthammer.com/index.php?cPath=33
Cross reference the titles with boardgamegeek.com and you should have a really good idea of what you're looking for.

In particular Rio Grande's cousin publisher Kosmos makes some excellent small two player games like Hera & Zeus, Kahuna and a couple LOTR themed games.

XBL
Jonman wrote:

Bullion Cube wrote:
Looks like a more frenetic God of War...for perverts.

*places pre-order*

Main Gauche
Donator V7.0
Robear's picture

Something like GOOTMU might hit the spot...Tons of laughs.

http://www.silcom.com/~tomjolly/goothome.htm

Old-school boardgaming zaniness for $15, can't be beat.

Then there's always the excellent "Illuminati" and "Hacker" from Steve Jackson Games. These are very good and have stood the test of time.

http://www.sjgames.com/ourgames/board.html

"My eyes! The goggles do nothing!" - McBain

Executive
Donator V5.0
croaker's picture
Location: N.J. U.S.A. -- Close enough.

Mixolyde wrote:
I highly recommend any *rails game for two players. Particularly Euro Rails and Empire Builder. Any more than 4 players slows the game down way too much. 2 players moves along pretty well.

We've four of the Mayfair "crayon" rail games: Empire Builder, Euro Rails, Lunar Rails, and Iron Dragon. They are all fun, but they're best with 3 or 4 players. With just two, some of the real interactions (like closing out small cities and proactive blocking track placement) just doesn't come into play. Of these, my favorite is Iron Dragon as it has the most going on.

These games are also great for putting aside until the next evening or so, as there is little state that isn't captured by what's on the board, making the extended play time doable when you've only got an hour or so of game time available.

"Gamers With Jobs will take over the world someday. I hope they're benevolent overlords." -- Bill Harris

Goes to 11
Donator V5.0
hubbinsd's picture
Location: The Circus of Values

Don't ever play Risk. The dice hate you. They are out to get you.

Xbox Live: hubbinsd

Coffee Grinder
ReggaeAmbassador's picture
Location: Charm City

I've played Ticked to Ride many, many times and can highly recommend it.

I'm not as impressed with Carcassone, although I do own the Hunters and Gatherers version. It adds a few twists to make the game a little more involved and strategic.

If you're looking for something that's a little more complex, the Rio Grande game Puerto Rico is really good.

You can call us Aaron Burr, from the way we're dropping Hamiltons