Recommended Fantasy Reading...
I'm on-and-off lurking these boards for well over a year by now, and in no small part due to the regularily appearing book discussions. Reading the resurrected Goodkind thread, it occured to me that I have bought a lot of outstanding books based on your recommendations lately, and so, it seems to me as though it might be a good idea to organize this joined library a little.
So, which fantasy authors and novels do you think deserve being recommended?
Before you begin, a few requests (Which you'll certainly ignore, anyway, but my own forums have been offline for a month and if I don't get to regulate something soon, I'm going to explode...):
*Fantasy is no easily defined genre. From the classic epic fantasies á la The Lord of the Rings to postmodern alternative reality tales such as American Gods, it's barely defineable, and often overlaps with other genres. Please don't start big debates about whether book a is in fact still fantasy or not.
*The genre did not begin with Tolkien. Feel free to cite other, older authors, be they Lovecraft, Dickens, or Goethe.
*Often, you'll want to generally suggest an author. In that case, please offer a choice title of his that you think deserves being read first and foremost by someone new to that writer.
*Please comment on your suggestions to explain the author's or book context in the genre.
Acceptable? Great. Then let me start with the no-brainers:
John R. R. Tolkien: The Hobbit, The Lord of the Rings.
OK, does anyone not know him? Tolkien's certainly the man who managed to turn existing mythical traditions into the basis for new literature and in so far the 'father' of the modern fantasy. His works should be read, if not for their prose, then for the sheer inventiveness of Middle Earth.
George R. Martin: The Song of Ice and Fire Series, other works.
I think everyone'll agree when I say that Martin's series is GWJ's fantasy epic of choice. Violent, mean, honest, thoughtful, imaginative, thrilling, deep, and incredibly well written.
Neil Gaiman: The Sandman series (comics), American Gods (novel), various others.
Certainly one of the finest writers of our time, Gaiman's generally very dark fiction is often described as 'shakespearian', in my perception justifiedly so. I put up American Gods as novel recommendation because everyone else seems to consider it his best piece of conventional prose, although I prefer Coraline. Just my crazed tastes.
Terry Pratchett: The Discworld series. Recommended first reads: Wyrd Sisters, Mort.
Another case of 'well, duh'. Maybe the living satirical writer.
China Mieville: The Scar.
I spent 600 bucks on books this year - this is the best thing I read in all of it. Mieville is a writer of brutal, merciless honesty. He's vocally socialist, and although he won't let his books become pamphlets, people starkly opposed to his views might not enjoy them as much, however.
OK, this much to get you going ![]()
And if I haven't seen further, it's because those bloody giants blocked my sight.


Maybe it is just me, but I was very unimpressed with American Gods.
Unfortunately, if I slash my wrist with my lightsaber it cauterizes instantly. - PurEvil on emo Star Wars plots.
I enjoy very much RA Salvatore''s books (thanks ShotgunPhil!). He has an excellent writing style and has matured over the process of writing his books. Start with teh Dark Elf Trilogy.
XBox Live: SwampYankee68
STEAM: SwampYankee
Well, as far as pre-Tolkien, ""The Worm Ouroboros"" comes to mind instantly...
I''m reading ""Perdido Street Station"" by Mieville right now; whoof! Very interesting, to say the least! Which prompts me to add all of M. John Harrison''s ""Viriconium"" novels/stories to this thread.
"Eat Keel, Hellbug!"
I enjoyed that one a lot, although the ending was sort of unsatisfying. I''ve been meaning to pick up Mieville''s other stuff...I like his style a lot.
Xbox Live: CrankyBaby
baggachipz: Who cares about Japan, let them have their silly pointless dog games and countless re-hashes of anime-based dragon princess super lucky crapitty crap.
I would say that a lot of his early work is fluff (Icewind Dale) but that some of the later things are much better. The Dark Elf trilogy (first chronologically, but released later) was pretty decent. The more recent stuff (Hunter''s Blades) hasn''t been bad at all, surprisingly enough..
But I must admit. I have a distinct weakness for even moderately well written sword and sorcery. Especially works set in Forgotten Realms. I have no idea why that is.
Skriss: lvl 70 undead mage - Bloodhoof
Kyrator: lvl 63 night elf rogue - Blackhand
Thadryn: lvl 70 draenei mage - Blackhand
If you''re looking for something different than the usual sword and sorcery fantasy epics, I suggest Tad Williams Otherland series. Although it starts slow, the blend of sci-fi and fantasy makes for a unique experience. Also features one of the best villains ever created.
Credulous at best, your desire to believe in angels in the hearts of men.
Hmm...
Neal Stephenson. Snowcrash is great. The Diamond Age is better. Definitely a hit or miss author. You love his style or you get lost. Most tech oriented folks seem to love his style.
Warren Ellis. Transmetropolitan. Spider Jerusalem is my hero. A story in comic book form. Collected volumes are available wherever fine comics are sold. Politics, religion, science, humanity, all in a post-scourge-of-ethics world. Quotable. Applicable. Human.
Poul Anderson. Harvest of Stars. Reading this story gives me hope for humanity. There are good people. There are philanthropists who look to their hearts and not the bottom line to justify an endeavor. Sadly I believe the window of opportunity for such development has passed in our particular tangent of reality. Fear will legislate away our dreams. ... ... Damn, it may be time for a re-read!
These are from memory...
Politely rude. Briskly vague. Firmly uninformative.
For those waiting for Martin, he did do an update on his site about ''A Feast for Crows'' in the beginning of November. While it''s mostly a lament about the US election results, he does devote one whole paragraph to the new book (third to the last):
About a Feast for Crows
The short of it: He hopes to be done by year end.
Joedeth
Ironjoe
I''m waiting for Iron Curtain to be released in paperback, and I''ve been meaning to pick up some of RA Salvatores Dragonlance titles, since you guys seem to like them much.
Other than that, its part 2 of first year law school.
Blog: GameFinance
Twitter: justinmwhitaker
Iron Council? Mieville''s 3rd book in the series? Definitely a good read. His ability to create unique fantasy races is very impressive considering a lot of authors just stick with the standard elf/dwarf/human combination.
In fact I named my new Troll warrior on Blackhand Stiltspear after one of the races introduced in this book.
WAR- Iron Rock - Cigaro/Engineer, Maersk/Witch Hunter
Too many favorite fantasy books to recommend, but thought I''d chime in with one of the lesser-known authors: Lawrence Watt-Evans''s fantasy books are absolutely amazing. His characters are generally quite realistic, normal people - incredibly rare in the Fantasy section of the bookstore. None of this ""Thou hast kiled my father, now I must slay you!"" silliness, or Evil Wizard Foozle cliches.
Try ""The Misenchanted Sword"" (or any of the other Ethshar series, many of which have recently been republished), ""The Lure of the Basilisk"", or ""Dragon Weather"". Quite possibly my favorite fantasy author, and I''ve read a lot of fantasy.
Everything can be debated, but that doesn't necessarily mean it's debatable.
--Chuck Klosterman, Fargo Rock City
I tried to read this one based on Karla''s recommendation and it just didn''t grab me. I felt he over-used metaphors to describe things and it completely took me out of the story every time he hit me with a new one. I never finished it.
Steven Erikson, Gardens of the Moon and other Tales of Malazan Book of the Fallen
Erickson is also a favorite around here, the first book in the series (Gardens on the Moon) takes a bit of perseverance because a lot of characters are introduced and you''re practically thrown right into the middle of a plot although the payoff is immense. The series tightens its focus around half-way through the first book and gets better and better as it goes on . Erickson has an incredible knack for world building and really gives the history of his world a lot of weight.
Certis beat me to it. - Elysium
One of the more unique fantasy sagas I''ve seen of late are David Drake''s ''Lord of the Isles'' series. They''re based off of Sumerian mythos and magic, and have quite a different (and interesting) flavor from the standard Tolkienesque type fantasies.
Stackpole''s ''Dragoncrown War Cycle'' wasn''t a half bad read, either (the final for it just came out on paperback). While I''ve always been a Stackpole fan (he''s done a lot of Mechwarrior and Star Wars stuff), the previous fantasy I''d read from him (''Once a Hero'') was utter crap (although it''s reviewed well on Amazon - so what do I know?). So I was a bit skeptical about more fantasy from him. I''d categorize it as ''popcorn'' fantasy. But that''s not a bad thing in my book.
Joedeth
Ironjoe
Outlaws of the Marsh
by Shi Nai''An
It is the book the Suikoden games are based on and is bloody fantastic. It is expnesive and hard to find but a great read.
For instance, there are 108 beads in a Catholic rosary and there are 108 stitches in a baseball. When I learned that, I gave Jesus a chance. ~Ron Shelton, Bull Durham, 1988
Sorry, I know it seems like I''m just dumping on books here but this is another series that started off well and slowly went down the drain. Haven''t even bothered reading the latest one. He had a great over-arching plot going and pretty much choose to ignore it and do a ""continuing adventures of"" kind of thing instead. Very disappointing.
Certis beat me to it. - Elysium
Well, I think the best ones have already been covered, but I''ll offer up a few of my own.
Stephen King The Dark Tower. I haven''t read the final book yet, but plan to pick it up soon. I''ve enjoyed the story, and the fact that it''s not your ""typical"" fantasy. Plus, King makes fun of himself in the 6th book, so he''s not taking himself too seriously.
Ricardo Pinto The Chosen. I''m sure most here have never heard of this guy. I picked up his first book on a trip visiting my dad and it had not yet been released in the U.S. (both it and the second book are available here now, however). It''s a fairly bizarre tale, and definately grim. I wouldn''t recommend it for everyone, but some people might enjoy it.
Eric Van Lustbader The Ring of Five Dragons. The first book in the series isn''t that great, but each one seems to improve. A nice blend of sci-fi and fantasy, with an interesting world and an overarching backstory that you actually want to learn about. Well, at least I do. Series isn''t done yet.
C.S. FriedmanThe Coldfire Trilogy. I read this a long time ago, and hope it has withstood the test of time, but when I read it I really enjoyed it. A unique setting and unusual blend of Sci-fi/fantasy that really leaves you thinking ""what if?""
I''ve got more, but I think that''s enough for now.
Graktar, Orc Hunter
No one has yet to mention the Wheel of Time series by Robert Jordan?
I have enjoyed this series (which is now awaiting its 11th book), although a couple of books we could have done without (like the 10th one. It ... was ... s ... l ... o ... w.) but overall a good series. If you have the time.
Fritz Leiber''s series starring Fahfard and the Grey Mouser has some excellent stories in it. So do Robert Howard''s several Conan books. Likewise, Fletcher Pratt was one of the greats and is often found in used bookstores and such.
For horror fantasy, HP Lovecraft has the most distinctive style and if you have an interest in New England history, you''ll enjoy his work. August Derleth is a worthy admirer of Lovecraft''s and worth hunting down, if you like the genre.
"Sometimes I go around saying, 'Kommisar Paulson has seized the commanding heights of the economy!'" - Paul Krugman, asked if recent changes to banking are socialistic.
Gene Wolfe''s New Sun series. The middle bit, the Long Sun books, being my absolute favorite. Immense charector depth and an epic storyline. Not only is he a great storyteller, he''s also one of the most skilled writers out there. At times I''d just stop and marvel at his structure.
For short and fun Fantasy, I''m working through Fritz Leibers Fafrd and the Gray Mauser''s tales. The Nebula award winning Ill Met in Lankhmar is a gem.
edit: Heh, You beat me Robear ). Nice to see someone else into Leiber. Have you read any of Wagner''s Kane series? Been trying to track those down.
http://rinkworks.com/bookaminute/b/jordan.eyeworld.shtml
Save yourself the time and aggravation.
I''m also going to HIGHLY recommend anything written by Gene Wolf. New Sun, Long Sun, short stories, novellas, anything and everything. Always a beautiful, interesting read, but keep dictionary.com handy.
Steam Id
Twitter
Mixol on XBL, couldn't recover my old account, sorry!
""Yah! Wah hah! This was the greatest book I''ve read in 3 second ever! Whoo hoo! This is the greatest 3-second series ever! Whoopie! Yee haw!""
Thanks for that link. I''ve never read the series myself, but that was too funny.
"There's too much blood in my caffeine system..."
BHA - Cuanos/Crowlie/Kasparov
For easier Wolfe to get your teeth into, I''d recommend his latest couple of books, The Knight and The Wizard.
The New Sun and Long Sun books are great but they can be.. intimidating. The Wizard-Knight (as he calls the two together) is much easier to get into and also damn good. Basically he''s doing a fairly cliched ''stolen by fairies'' and ''person from the real world becomes a hero in a fantasy world'' story, but many times better than other authors would do it.
Also, his books Soldier of the Mist and Soldier of Arete are great fantasy for those into the classics. Following a Latin mercenary from Xerxes'' army in the Persian invasion of Greece, it presents the world as the people back then thought of it - gods, nymphs and monsters are all real and often get involved.
Another recent find is another New Zealander, Russell Kirkpatrick. I''ve only read the first book of his trilogy (called ""Across the Face of the World"") but it was very good indeed. Similar style to Tolkien without just being a rip off. He''s a geographer and mapmaker, apparently, and his love of that comes through in the story the way Tolkien''s love of languages and history did in his work. Not sure if you North American''s can get it yet, as the edition I read was from an Australian publisher.
While you won''t find me saying this is the greatest series ever, it does have some good moments that I am sure that synopsis of book 1 left out. Book 7 was the best (hmmm ... I also think it was the shortest.)
Now book 4 took me an eon to read and book 10 ... I envy those souls that finished reading this book. I was not one of them. Book 10 you can completely skip and not miss anything in the series.
Granted, I''m a bit biased because generic high fantasy really bores me. But, IMHO, even for that genre Jordan is predictable, mundane, lengthy and tedious. It''s all the worst parts of Tolkien times ten. I''d prefer something that forges some new ground instead of the lowest common denominator of every other fantasy series.
Steam Id
Twitter
Mixol on XBL, couldn't recover my old account, sorry!
Damn you guys and making me buy books...
Now, not only am I going to go to Barnes and Noble and probably spend multiple tens of dollars on books tonight, but then I''ll have all these books, and not know what to do with them. And, The Daily Show''s America will get read EVEN SLOWER...
XBox Live Gamertag: Warlockbert
Well for an interesting change of pace, some/all of you might consider the ""Amber"" series by Roger Zelazny- I read about the first five, then kind of lost interest. I believe there are 2 or 3 ""combined"" volumes now.
"Eat Keel, Hellbug!"
I was going to mention Zelazny--he is one of the all-time greats, and a big influence on guys like Gaiman.
Xbox Live: CrankyBaby
baggachipz: Who cares about Japan, let them have their silly pointless dog games and countless re-hashes of anime-based dragon princess super lucky crapitty crap.
I''ll second the recommendations for Leiber''s Fahfard and the Grey Mouser books, as well as Robert E. Howard''s Conan books and HP Lovecraft generally.
Zelazny is required reading. He''s one of the most graceful writers I''ve ever read.
Gene Wolfe is interesting, but can be very difficult. I very much ... admired the New Sun books, but failed to get into the Long Sun series. I recommend starting with a book of his short stories to acclimate yourself to his style.
China Mieville: I recently read Perdido Street Station. For the first third, I was fascinated and amazed by his imagination. By the end of the book, I was absolutely disgusted with his writing. Like many writers, he is incapable of plotting. He has a neat imagination, but it is undisciplined and he threw interesting scenes and events into the book without any attempt to connect them to his overall story. These are forgivable sins, however. What absolutely disgusted me about the book was the horrible, horrible resolution at the end. It seemed that at every point through the final pages where he had the chance to tie up a thread into a satisfying conclusion, he deliberately chose an infuriating and painful alternative. The experience was so unpleasant that I doubt I''ll ever read another of his books again.
I''m reading Philip Pullman''s His Dark Materials trilogy. The first book is great. The second book is mostly great. I''m only a little way into the third book, but other people have told me that they have lots of problems with the way it wraps up.
I recommend looking into a mostly forgotten writer named Jack Vance. You can probably find a compendium titled Tales of the Dying Earth at your local bookstore. The first volume in that compendium, The Dying Earth, is probably my favorite book. I also recommend any of his other short story collections. The Last Castle and The Dragon Masters won major awards. The Lyonesse trilogy is the closest thing he''s done to a traditional high fantasy trilogy, but I wouldn''t start with it.
Vance has an unusual writing style that takes a while to get used to and doesn''t appeal to everybody. George R.R. Martin has said that he much admired Vance''s works, and one of Martin''s short story collections - Tuf Voyaging - looks like a deliberate attempt to write a series of stories in Vance''s odd and unusual style.
The original Riftwar saga by Raymond E. Feist is another I''d recommend. I read that as a kid and really liked it. Nothing terribly original, but a good epic fantasy romp. I haven''t really read the later novels in this setting, mostly because I liked the original characters too much to care about books written about different characters.
Graktar, Orc Hunter
I have very much enjoyed reading and re-reading Steven Brust''s Vlad Taltos series. His other books are ok but you really have to like him as an author to get past the somewhat funky style of writing he uses in the prequel series. He has done several other books outside his usual fantasy world one of which was called Cowboy Feng''s Space Bar and Grill which was also excellent though more cyberpunk than fantasy I suppose.
I can''t currently remember the author''s name but the Dragon Sleeping (first book I think) was very good as was the whole Silver Gryphon series (again can''t remember the author.)