Halo 4, Assassin's Creed III: Liberation, Forza Horizon, Unity of Command, Special Guest 343 Industries' David Ellis, Your Emails and more!
This week 343 Industries' Halo 4 developer David Ellis joins us to talk about his game. Spoiler section included!
To contact us, email [email protected]! Send us your thoughts on the show, pressing issues you want to talk about or whatever else is on your mind. You can even send a 30 second audio question or comment (MP3 format please) if you're so inclined.
Jonathan Downin About.Me
Tweaked Audio (Use discount code GWJ)
Chairman_Mao's Timestamps
00.01:58 Forza: Horizon
00.12.30 Assassin's Creed III: Liberation
00.27.38 Dishonored
00.36.04 Unity of Command
00.42.07 Halo 4
01.19.49 Your emails!
01.38.06 Halo 4 Spoiler Section!
Main theme - Halo: CE - http://www.halowaypoint.com/en-us/ - 41:36
Main theme - Halo 3 - http://www.halowaypoint.com/en-us/ - 1:19:22
Main theme - Halo 4 - http://www.halowaypoint.com/en-us/ - 1:38:05
Intro/Outtro Music - Ian Dorsch, Willowtree Audioworks
Comments
Pages
Haven't finished the podcast yet, but I wanted to get in one comment.
Rabbit you son of a Female Doggo, why'd you equate the Brotherhood Assassin Management crap to Farmville? If Ubisoft hasn't made it, then that is a Facebook game I might actually play. I cannot explain why I enjoyed sending Assassins on missions and leveling them up, but I did.
You bastard.
Also: I like Shawn's comparison between Halo and Zelda in terms of a formula that works. There is something genius about the initial design of all the Covenant and their weapons, though to me any time Bungie has tried to make additions to that formula or slight modifications it has typically not fit as well.
Though truth told, part of me does kind of miss seeing the Drones on occasion. Drones and Brutes were typically good at providing some level of variety to help break up the typical perfect team of Elite-Grunt-Jackal. Though not the Brutes from Halo 3. They were just tedious.
I do want to thank 343 for making the Needler bad ass again.
YouTube | Twitch | Blog
SW-3864-9679-7572
Tuesdays used to be new music release day and Thursdays was new movie/game release day. Around 5 years ago or so (maybe more now) they ended up merging them all into Tuesday release. Of course there's occasional exceptions.
Oh my favorite way to eliminate knights is to use the shotgun. 2 shots and they're gone.
Gamer Tag: Rantyr
eff yes, another long one. good job guys.
Steam: BagelMage
Twitter: @BagelMage
Twitch Stream: bagelmage.tv
Seconded. The needler became my favourite weapon in the original Halo. Feeding a stream of needles onto a tricky elite was very satisfying.
A very nice discussion about Halo 4 all round. I think may be on board (I didn't want to be. What happened to the good old days when 80% of games could be reliably dismissed as sub par.)
For the record my favourite Halo's: 1, 3 (I liked those brutes :)) and Reach... or to put it another way... 2 was the only one I was lukewarm on. The combat felt to fast to be fun, especially towards the end.
I hope you like thrill rides - Luis Serra, Resident Evil 4 Remake
Uncharted 4 Multiplayer: Half Nelson
Listened to the entire podcast now. Honestly, this is one of the reasons I love you guys. As I'm sitting there listening, I wish I could speak up and throw my voice in. I wish I could be a part of the conversation. There's so much I would love to say, but I can't even think of it all.
So instead, in regards to the spoiler section...
YouTube | Twitch | Blog
SW-3864-9679-7572
Awesome podcast as usual. What was even more awesome was hearing that there are a number of staff members at 343 who regularly listen to the conference call.
Twitter - @mudbunny74
BlueSky - @mudbunny.bsky.social
Battle.net - mudbunny#1327
Best spoiler section I have ever heard from you guys (or any podcast for that matter). I always enjoy them, especially since I know I won't play a lot of the games you do this for, and this gives me a way of hearing my friends talk about the entire game and telling me how awesome/crappy it is. But having the guy from 343 on brought it to a whole new level for me. I can't remember off hand having you guys do this before, but definitely look in to doing it for future spoiler sections. In spite of his side-steppy-ness (yes, that is a term now...) in answering some questions his insights were great. And I loved that you guys did not pull any punches.
Great job as always, gentlemen.
The whispering in the background around 2 hours in made me feel possessed. There was whispering, right? ...Right?
Long live the new flesh.
PSN: videoheadsystem
Wow, Rabbit, you came off like a drunken asshole in that spoiler section o_o We get it, your son was able to figure out where the enemies were going to pop out and you didn't like the earlier games in the series. Eesh.
!!
Fair enough.
Last.fm | Twitter
"If I knew you could claim podcast hosts that way, I would had peed on you back at Tamo." - AgentWred
Wow, overloaded, you came off like a drunken asshole in that post o_o We get it, you heard something on a podcast you didn't agree with. Eesh.
It wasn't what he was saying (which I didn't particularly disagree with), it was how he was saying it. Repetition, tone, phrasing. "I didn't give a *sh*t* about.." - that sort of thing. I'm not saying you should suck up to devs, but there's asking pointed questions about things you didn't like and there's being rude. It seemed out of character, which is why I mention it. I also don't know if you guys are long time friends or something, which could account for the tone.
!!
Actually that was one of the things I was going to respond to. I agree that this Halo seemed more predictable than ever, and that gondola I thought the exact same thing. But I was also on that gondola (twice!) in Halo 2, and on several bridges in Halo 1, and this set piece and that set piece and etc. I think this is part of Halo 4 sticking to the Halo formula very close to the chest.
YouTube | Twitch | Blog
SW-3864-9679-7572
Long time listener, first time poster; yadda, yadda yadda.
I think rabbit made a fair assessment; the game entertained and was used as a father-son experience. I agree with what rabbit says; there are very few FPS that allow for this, especially with rabbit's son being 7. 8? I can't remember.
What did annoy me quite a bit was rabbit talking over the guest. repeatedly.
I love every episode; as many have stated, the openness and camaraderie make listeners want to be part of the conversation.
This is the first time that I felt that I would get talked over. rabbit hardly let the guest (can't remember his name) say a single sentence without being interrupted.
Everything else was spot on. As always. Keep up the great work.
The spoiler section actually made Halo interesting to me. Well done.
The release of Spartan Ops for Xbox Live Gold reminds me of Sony releasing free games for PS Plus. It sounds like Microsoft is experimenting with this idea.
Most places: Aristophan | Switch: SW-7774-7919-6764
Just wanted to throw this out there - while not quite as old as Rabbit, the first game I ever finished was Adventure on the Atari 2600. Games I had to program myself on my TSR-80 don't count.
A Cigar, much like Scotch and Monogamy, is an acquired taste.
The best parenting advice I've seen:
SMBC wrote:Your quest is to convince me that you deserve to sleep indoors.
Adventure was my first game, too. Although, it was not the longest of games.
The spoiler section was great, and yet hard to listen to. I like that you guys didn't pull punches on the developer sitting in the hot chair -- but wow did you stick it to him. He handled it extremely well too, he should be proud.
I respect all the GWJ guys from listening to so many of their podcasts, but Rabbit, this almost sounded like there's a part of you that sort of CAN'T like a Halo game... not fully. You're almost wrestling with yourself throughout the podcast. And that's not a crime, but I guess I want to flag that you sort of wielded that internal conflict as a Nerf bat on the developer, when really it just comes down to recognizing that no Halo is ever going to be fully to your taste.
The developer tried to defend his team on the following point, but I don't think it is underlined enough. Contrary to Rabbit's rant, the game and the plot WERE intertwined. Cortana has been, in many ways, our ambassador to plot during gameplay in all the Halos. This continued in Halo 4, but I saw a subtlety or sensitivity in this area that had been ham-fisted (gravity hammered?) in place in previous iterations; so carefully was it woven throughout that I found it engaging and heartening for future games in this series. And so I was sort of devastated to hear Rabbit harp on this one point so heavily. I actually said aloud to my computer "No! It's good! Leave that guy alone! We're alright!"
I found myself thinking many of the same things as Rabbit, but to a less intense degree. "This seems familiar!" I said at the gondola part and many other parts as well; and it is great that his son could pick up on those patterns, but complete deviation from most of those patterns would probably not seem like a Halo game, I guess. And as the developer pointed out, that's ONLY a good thing for this particular game, given that 343 has just grabbed that torch from Bungie's hands; and making it approachable for n00bs as well. Also, keep in mind, that ammo dump that was simple to predict and find on your "easy" run-through is an oasis of safety that we MUST know is there, and might have incredible difficulty getting to, on our "Legendary" run-throughs.
#damnfinecoffee XBL: dRailer
I don't know, the discussion with David closely resembles off mic discussions we have with a great many game developers sitting at a bar. David had a good time and we're looking forward to having him back to talk about Halo and non-Halo stuff in the future.
Julian was clear on his bias and personal experience/struggles with Halo from the get go and we gave David full license to have us edit out anything he wasn't comfortable with. We have nothing to gain getting people in trouble with their employers.
I guess it can be jarring to hear a frank, passionate discussion with a developer when we're so used to hearing them handled with gentle care. What seems to be classified as disrespectful to some was us just talking like dudes hanging out to me. Sometimes we can get blustery and repetitive when we're in the mix of it but I don't really see that as a bad thing.
I'm sure I'd feel differently if our jobs were on the line and we had to worry about good relations with PR and ad people. But we don't thanks to your donations and our independence. It's a good thing.
“Don’t ask what the world needs. Ask what makes you come alive, and go do it. Because what the world needs is people who have come alive.” ― Howard Thurman
I think that's fair. I'll gladly give up the point I made about Julian probably not liking any Halo game. And I didn't think anything in the podcast was disrespectful at all. To your own point during the podcast, such commentary probably could be said back around Halo 2 and 3, so perhaps the criticisms just feel a bit striking at the current time: I'm looking at a series of games that has mostly been about machismo, finally finding a more human side and felt a lot of joy at how expertly this is coming to light. I'm likely getting a bit defensive that this isn't being met with the fanfare that I felt. My apologies if the above post was a bit overstated.
#damnfinecoffee XBL: dRailer
None necessary! My reply was more general rather than directed just at you. I enjoyed your post
“Don’t ask what the world needs. Ask what makes you come alive, and go do it. Because what the world needs is people who have come alive.” ― Howard Thurman
I think this is the whole reason for the rabbit response team. It was a really good chat, and very interesting to hear.
Steam: Atras
PSN: Atras126
XBox Live: Atras
Yeah, for what it's worth I didn't think Rabbit was talking over the developer any more than anyone talks during any of the podcasts.
YouTube | Twitch | Blog
SW-3864-9679-7572
So, I cop to having conflicted feelings about Halo, and perhaps being a bit aggressive in that conversation. I want everything to be awesome, I'm generally hyper enthusiastic about everything.
As for the "talking over" -- in all our defense, we've been having worse than usual skype lag during our recordings (thanks Microsoft!) which can make that a bit problematic. We generally err on the side of "just keep talking and let the producer duck tracks if needed" because the alternative is a lot of "no no you go ..." which I find EXCRUCIATING to listen to.
Last.fm | Twitter
"If I knew you could claim podcast hosts that way, I would had peed on you back at Tamo." - AgentWred
I enjoyed all the Halo 4 chat.
Halo, more than any other game I can think of, is a vastly different experience on different difficulty settings. Playing the first Halo on a lower difficulty left me feeling underwhelmed and more than a little disappointed. When I played through again on the next difficulty level up the game suddenly came alive.
In a sense it's a flaw in the game that it doesn't work half as well when played in certain ways.
I hope you like thrill rides - Luis Serra, Resident Evil 4 Remake
Uncharted 4 Multiplayer: Half Nelson
Just a quick question - I'm part-way through this episode (listening as I commute to/from work) so apologies if this is clarified later in the podcast. At one point David Ellis asks "have you watched the CGI episode for Spartan Ops?", to which is answered "yes, we didn't skip anything".
That makes me wonder if you guys actually did watch it, or was there a miscommunication and confusion between the actual CGI episode and the couple seconds of in-game rendered cut-scene at the start of the mission.
Or it just may be me misinterpreting the response. The question popped into my head because the CGI episode can't be watched in coop mode (it's a separate menu option on the Spartan Ops menu), which is the way you guys said you played it, and it's not something you would "skip" (i.e. hit Y or whatever) like the in game scene at the start of the mission.
Probably a stupid question, but I felt compelled to ask . . . .
Well a lot of that is simply due to major adjustments in the A.I. as well. The lower difficulties are for people that are fighting the controller as much as they are the Covenant. When you boost the difficulty enemies not only do more damage, but they're more accurate, they're more willing to throw grenades, they're more assertive and even the Grunts will freak out less frequently (as opposed to Normal where you fire a gun shot and they start running).
YouTube | Twitch | Blog
SW-3864-9679-7572
I also need to weigh in on rabbit's opinion... about Bethesda's in-game books. My wife and I went on vacation a little while after Skyrim came out, and I felt naturally that a log cabin with a wood fire and a big blanket needs an iPhone with the ebook of all the Skyrim fiction.
And it was great! Some was awful (the Last Seed volumes, IIRC), some was truly enjoyable (The Black Arrow) and enriching from a world-building perspective (The Argonian Account), and a lot was plain really long (so many histories) and I never would have read it otherwise—and since Morrowind I never had. I don't normally give a dingo's kidneys for so-called "lore"—especially video game lore—but I'm invested in TES and I give a bit more credit to Beth's fiction.
There are great ways to give depth to video game worlds, and terrible ways. Unskippable infodump cutscenes or encyclopedic codex entries are not the great ways. Inviting but optional in-world voices suggesting a larger world and history, whether it's small-scope like Thief or grander like TES, are.
Gravey, I'm never sure, on a scale of 1-10, just how serious you are when you post. – Minarchist
Great podcast. I thought it was really interesting hearing David talk about the Halo AI. Especially, how it reacts to players and how they prevent it from using network bandwidth.
I recently finished the game solo on Heroic and thought it was great. Unlike most other modern shooters, Halo doesn't make me hate it when I die over and over. The set pieces combined with the AI make it really fun to experiment with different strategies.
In terms of the story, put me in the park of "Master chief is is really big and kills craploads of aliens". (I listened to the podcast a few days ago so that may not be an exact quote)
One thing that I just wanted to point out from Rabbit's Halo 4 rant - Rabbit kept pointing out that his son saw all the twists and game mechanics coming. Rabbit did not say that he had those same observations. Maybe the little rabbit is a little more observant than the big rabbit?
A Cigar, much like Scotch and Monogamy, is an acquired taste.
The best parenting advice I've seen:
SMBC wrote:Your quest is to convince me that you deserve to sleep indoors.
Pages